Suspected LCL tear for Reynolds, 4-5 months out if confirmed by scans.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
If I was James Graham, I'd walk the team off
Collapse
X
-
Im confused with the rules I thought you couldnt attack the legs of a player who was in the air or if you were in the air So now you can slide two metres into someones legs who is stationery on the ground and be penalised Can someone find that rule and post it here I dont think the rule was brought in for what happened today it is a massive stretch to say that is a penaltyI respect all our moderators here. Past present and even future. Always have done and always will do a wonderful job.
Comment
-
Originally posted by LargeMike View Post
The amateur hour refereeing argument can be saved for another thread.
Refs got the call right which makes the madness that ensued look even worse then it was.!!!!!
Comment
-
-
I think the referee made the correct call. But what I found more offensive was Inglis holding Graham back by the throat after Graham did the right thing and stayed down with Reynold's, calling for assistance. Inglis is anything but a class-act.
Comment
-
I agree with the last penalty. Whilst graham wasn't intentionally attacking the kickers legs it was "careless and reckless". This has been the rule for a long time.
Protection of kickers goes back to Easts and Manly legend Ron Rambo Gibbs who would intentionally throw himself at kickers knees. The rules were changed because of him. Just like Inglis killed the shoulder charge and Billy Slater is largely responsible for the "boots first 8 point try". It sucks for the Bulldogs who clearly dominated today's game but sometimes the better team loses and the rules are the rules.
Comment
-
Geez, I swear I have logged into the Kennel after reading this thread....a barrel of laughs (or is it a Keg of laughs?).
We have been shafted by the Dogs plenty of times so if they were shafted by the Vermin scum they don't get my sympathy.
I couldn't be bothered watching a game between those two scummy clubs so I went to a strip club instead.
I just checked a couple of minutes on a screen in the club just before half-time. Total dross and mistake ridden, we have the comp in the bag refs or no refs...no one will get near us so let us not start suggesting Souffs will win it. They won't win it this year if we want it badly enough...no matter how much the NRL wants them to go back to back if that is the case. They only won it last year because we didn't want it bad enough.
They are vermin scum, they are inferior to us....believe it people the, team now does so should we...
Carry on troops!
Comment
-
When Souths play Dogs I'm actually in a state of utter confusion for 2 hrs, trying to decide who I hate the more. So I actually don't give a $ hit who got ripped off or who won. The bottom line is tho he took out the kickers legs. Whether he meant to or not is irrelevant. And if Elo is right then that's all the proof you need. You just can't do that.
For what it's worth I thought Klemmer was outstanding. Took it to the Burgess boys all day. His body shape seems to have changed. Lost all that baby fat he had. Going to be a very very good player.Last edited by John Corey; 04-03-2015, 08:05 PM.Embrace the Hate! JC
Comment
-
Originally posted by Lauren View PostI think the referee made the correct call. But what I found more offensive was Inglis holding Graham back by the throat after Graham did the right thing and stayed down with Reynold's, calling for assistance. Inglis is anything but a class-act.
Comment
Comment