Originally posted by milanja
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Maubs close to re-signing
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by Madrooster View PostI do. But I wouldn't be making a judgement and support it with that stat. Especially I would be interested to compare with other stats that I mentioned, because the stat you gave is misleading when all is considered. Especially as a backrower. It's all relative.
Originally posted by Madrooster View PostAre you happy with the other 1000 stats that have been taken of Aubs? Hit ups, offloads, metres per run, tackle busts etc etc that you want your backrower to be excelling in?
Originally posted by Madrooster View PostWithout trolling stats pages, which I am not into and in a good percentage of instances I believe they mean next to little any way, I think his performance is lacking for a backrower that I would want to offer 3 years to. I admire Maubs as a player and would like to see him remain at the club, but at this stage I don't know based on his 'stats' or his purpose in the squad that I would be throwing 3 years at him. I think Guerra is better fit for our left edge and our team on a whole.
Comment
-
Maubs is one of the best hole runners in the NRL in my opinion.
He was a bit quiet last year, but that was after a pretty serious injury.
Looking at the defensive stats only puts him higher up in my book.
I rate Maubs highly, but I don't think I could justify paying anything more than 300k for him, raised salary cap or not.
Comment
-
I know his days as a centre are probably behind him, but I salivate at the prospect of him playing outside SBW. It would be a match made in heaven imo - maubs' mobility and brilliant hole running working off SBW's power and skill. Imo, if we were to do it, it wouldnt even necessarily be a case of maubs playing 'outside SBW'. I could see them both swapping between backrow and centre (ie playing wider and tighter) which would add a great deal of unpredictability but also make them both far more dangerous in attack because they can effectively share the backrower's share of the work and also take a good amount of defensive work from pearce who imo, still does way too much defence for a 7. We could do worse things than:
1. RTS
2. Minichiello
3. Jennings
4. Maubs
5. SKD
Comment
-
Originally posted by roz View PostI know his days as a centre are probably behind him, but I salivate at the prospect of him playing outside SBW. It would be a match made in heaven imo - maubs' mobility and brilliant hole running working off SBW's power and skill. Imo, if we were to do it, it wouldnt even necessarily be a case of maubs playing 'outside SBW'. I could see them both swapping between backrow and centre (ie playing wider and tighter) which would add a great deal of unpredictability but also make them both far more dangerous in attack because they can effectively share the backrower's share of the work and also take a good amount of defensive work from pearce who imo, still does way too much defence for a 7. We could do worse things than:
1. RTS
2. Minichiello
3. Jennings
4. Maubs
5. SKD
Remember when we had the slowest centre combo in the comp a few years ago with Soliola/Sa and aubs in the centres :/Comment of the year:
Andrew Johns, Semi-Final vs North Queensland ,
"It's touched Lui's hand and travelled forward but that's not a knock on"
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Johnny. View PostIf Gallen isn't out of the game for injecting Gorilla hormones (that's a joke ASADA) then he'd be 32 and well past it.
Comment
-
Originally posted by davos View PostWe spent years playing Aubs in the centres and he was more useless than a useless thing. He only found his feet during his career when he moved into the backrow.
Remember when we had the slowest centre combo in the comp a few years ago with Soliola/Sa and aubs in the centres :/
Comment
-
Roz I'm not convinced he's up to defending in the centres anymore. Last year his defence was shocking there.
I can only put it down to the fact that he's bulked up a lot and doesn't have the mobility or speed needed to defend in the centers that he used to have. Have no doubts he could handle the attack side of it all...
Comment
-
Originally posted by Rooster_6 View PostRoz I'm not convinced he's up to defending in the centres anymore. Last year his defence was shocking there.
I can only put it down to the fact that he's bulked up a lot and doesn't have the mobility or speed needed to defend in the centers that he used to have. Have no doubts he could handle the attack side of it all...
I don't think Maubs is a long term option for centre but if someone went down he is the first guy I would put in there.
They way he plays I don't think much would change.
Anyway at the right price I'm happy to have him.
Comment
Comment