We had two captain challenges and he got both wrong. That has to be a first!
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Bunker - Fraud watch
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by Dr. Voodoo Man View PostWhat about the Knights going up 8 to 0 because we didn't have a ball. It was a Knights home game. I was dumbfounded.
- 7 likes
Comment
-
Originally posted by Bates View Post
Sutton to Keary " It's your responsibility to get the ball" WTF? now players must jump the fence and go looking for a footy according to Gerard Sutton. These clowns never seem to amaze me.
- 3 likes
Comment
-
Originally posted by zac View Postwas a shocker from the bunker and not the first.
that said, we could have done better. lindsay called for the review cos he knew he'd been hit in the melon. he should have made it clear that he'd been hit in the melon by saying 'i've been hit in the ****en melon' and by bringing his arm up to his head re-creating what happened. hard for the bunker to miss it then. if we're going to call for reviews that highlight foul play even though we know there's no knock on (which i don't have a problem with) then we have to be all in.
and while we're at it, makes sense to have a review of whether or not the players stay down when they know they've been fouled. yes, there are reasons to play the game in the right spirit but not when nobody else does and it pisses us of when we lose out of it. plus, refs factor into their decisions whether or not a player has appealed for a foul. they assume that players will appeal for fouls and when they don't they can assume that no foul has been committed
1. We probably wouldn't get anything from the refs. It wouldn't magically make refs more generous towards us.
2. We'd run the risk of teams putting serious metres on us while we're down. IMO Robbo is right to teach our boys that you get up and play to the whistle. For the occasional penalty we MIGHT get (probably won't), IMO there's probably at least 10 scenarios where we'd end up doing stupid shyte because we're begging for a penalty instead of playing footy.
3. It's all part of our mental game. If we start crying 'poor us' then our whole mental game would change.
- 1 like
Comment
-
Originally posted by Rooster_6 View PostDaniel Saifiti has been charged for high contact on Lindsay Collins but we lost the challenge because Chris Butler said it was only and I quote "slight contact" whilst Lindsay Collins was on the field spitting blood.
We need to start a fraud watch on the bunker I'm struggling to keep up. Bad calls happen on the run but when you've got access to 15 HD cameras with ultra slow-mo play back you've got to do better.
ROUND 4 - Chris Butler incorrectly penalises JWH for obstruction, try removed from Roosters.
ROUND 5 - Todd Smith incorrectly sends Victor Radley to the sin bin for a phantom hip drop.
ROUND 6 - Chris Butler Incorrectly deems force in high tackle that left Lindsay Collins bleeding from the mouth as only "slight contact"
What else am I missing?
- 1 like
Comment
-
Originally posted by Juggler View PostWhat about Gagai’s quick tap and knock on after running 10m + being called back and given a kick for touch due to no quick taps for foul play? I thought it was for holding down or inside 10 in the 40m. Fox didn’t show his signal.
- 3 likes
Comment
-
Originally posted by zac View Postwas a shocker from the bunker and not the first.
that said, we could have done better. lindsay called for the review cos he knew he'd been hit in the melon. he should have made it clear that he'd been hit in the melon by saying 'i've been hit in the ****en melon' and by bringing his arm up to his head re-creating what happened. hard for the bunker to miss it then. if we're going to call for reviews that highlight foul play even though we know there's no knock on (which i don't have a problem with) then we have to be all in.
and while we're at it, makes sense to have a review of whether or not the players stay down when they know they've been fouled. yes, there are reasons to play the game in the right spirit but not when nobody else does and it pisses us of when we lose out of it. plus, refs factor into their decisions whether or not a player has appealed for a foul. they assume that players will appeal for fouls and when they don't they can assume that no foul has been committed
Comment
-
Originally posted by The Marshall View PostYes that was another one that O BRIEN conveniently forgot when he was whinging about how badly his team got treated by the refs.
- 2 likes
Comment
-
Originally posted by Thirteen View PostIt’s just good to know that if a player knocks on, you are allowed to smash him in the head afterwards with no consequences. Hopefully next time we play Souths, Cody or Latrell knock on and then Victor knocks out their teeth with a high shot.
- 2 likes
Comment
-
Originally posted by zac View Postwas a shocker from the bunker and not the first.
that said, we could have done better. lindsay called for the review cos he knew he'd been hit in the melon. he should have made it clear that he'd been hit in the melon by saying 'i've been hit in the ****en melon' and by bringing his arm up to his head re-creating what happened. hard for the bunker to miss it then. if we're going to call for reviews that highlight foul play even though we know there's no knock on (which i don't have a problem with) then we have to be all in.
and while we're at it, makes sense to have a review of whether or not the players stay down when they know they've been fouled. yes, there are reasons to play the game in the right spirit but not when nobody else does and it pisses us of when we lose out of it. plus, refs factor into their decisions whether or not a player has appealed for a foul. they assume that players will appeal for fouls and when they don't they can assume that no foul has been committed
- 2 likes
Comment
-
Originally posted by SamKerrSimp View Post
There was a ball in the in goal and in the bucket directly behind the ball that's on our players being dumb and Gerrard Sutton as much as I dislike his performances last night clearly explained that to Keary.Last edited by Bates; 04-12-2024, 08:15 PM.
Comment
-
https://twitter.com/FOXNRL/status/17...463340272?s=19
so now we have an actual hip drop but it's not a sin bin offence...
Bunker in disarray.
- 3 likes
Comment
-
A few from Trent Robinson that I'm sure most of us remember.
NRL Presser: Robbo blows up over the bunker! | NRL on Nine (youtube.com)"Do you expect me to talk"? "No, Mr. Bond, I expect you to die".
Comment
-
53rd minute. When May offloaded back and Sutton called a knock on and we challenged it. When the bunker said Knights knock on did you see Sutton's WTAF reaction? Two tackles later he found a penalty for Rads obstruction which seemed very tough.
Gus' fumble then hitting it backwards before it hit the ground was also a BS knock on call.
- 5 likes
Comment
-
Comment