So who hates who????

[stsae]

could we pay cherry 250k then let anasta go to another club for the difference?

We have 3 halves why would we buy another???

[Guest]

We have 3 halves why would we buy another???

cherry is cheaper and better than anasta?

[stsae]

cherry is cheaper and better than anasta?

How do you know what either earns??? Or could potentially earn???

How do you know Cherry won't get the 2nd year jimmys???

Not that I believe he will, but it's happened many times before.

Also who do you offload Bwaiff to??? Golf ain't gonna work.

[Guest]

So Noyce did all that???

Party culture??? Ever see the boys party in 02???

Who said there is nothing wrong with the club???

You sound like you're angry John. Are you a frustrated administrator, player or coach???

I'm neither a Yid, a doctor nor a foreign skipper.

I just know that we could have had a dynasty but for a few bad choices.

And to clarify, I just don't rate Steve Noyce as a CEO.

2002 is looking to be an aberration rather than the norm.

[Guest]

braith to panthers or souths . we pay him 400k pa. cherry is on 135k pa. and has many years of nrl to come.

[Roostarz]

As much as I agree with you Tiptop, Braith is here to stay methinks and we don't want him in the forwards. So 5/8 is the only option. I think Cherry-Evans is a very good mature young player and will have many years at the top grade.

[stsae]

I'm neither a Yid, a doctor nor a foreign skipper.

I just know that we could have had a dynasty but for a few bad choices.

And to clarify, I just don't rate Steve Noyce as a CEO.

2002 is looking to be an aberration rather than the norm.

Only 2 clubs create dynasties of sorts now John, and they are owned by the same company.

The rest of us grab our chances when we get them.

I do agree we haven taken our chances when we had them often enough.

John, if you had balls of crystal, and you saw the next 11yrs would mirror the last 11, would you take that??? Or prefer the 11yrs before that era, or the 11 before that, you know the 80s and 90s???

[stsae]

braith to panthers or souths . we pay him 400k pa. cherry is on 135k pa. and has many years of nrl to come.

We just order them to take him??? And Souffs with Sutton and Bwaiff in the halves, lol.

Who told you what bread they earn???

[Kingbilly]

Anasta is not the greatest player, but without him we would have been dead last 3 years in a row.
Carney would have been a head case in 2010 as well as 2011.

I don't give a flying eff if you can't stomach this fact, but its the truth.
There are a few here that hate Anasta and thats fine but some go on and are blinded by some personal hatred for him and Smith.
Anasta hated Carney because he was unprofessional and didn't have the club's best interest at heart. Thats good enough for me.

People have a go at me about bagging Fittler, fine a lot of that is tongue in cheek, he was a terrific player who unfortunately and probably due to injury didn't perform in 2, bugger that 3 GFs. He was also a ****wit off the field, that until he attempted to coach had no effect.
Neverless I will always be greatful to Fittler to all the good stuff he brough to the club.

[stsae]

Anasta is not the greatest player, but without him we would have been dead last 3 years in a row.
Carney would have been a head case in 2010 as well as 2011.

I don't give a flying eff if you can't stomach this fact, but its the truth.
There are a few here that hate Anasta and thats fine but some go on and are blinded by some personal hatred for him and Smith.
Anasta hated Carney because he was unprofessional and didn't have the club's best interest at heart. Thats good enough for me.

People have a go at me about bagging Fittler, fine a lot of that is tongue in cheek, he was a terrific player who unfortunately and probably due to injury didn't perform in 2, bugger that 3 GFs. He was also a ****wit off the field, that until he attempted to coach had no effect.
Neverless I will always be greatful to Fittler to all the good stuff he brough to the club.

Hatred is fine. But some constantly bang on, and I think they actually believe, that our coach and captain and board want us to lose. It's pretty bizarre when you think of it.

What I don't get is why people didn't have the same concerns at the end of 2010??? All of a sudden Bwaiff can't play in the forwards and is a shit captain, Smiffs a fool and Noyce is a dreg. Funny they weren't the ones missing crucial tackles every week and playing like girls. Only one player acted that way, sadly.

[Guest]

We just order them to take him??? And Souffs with Sutton and Bwaiff in the halves, lol.

Who told you what bread they earn???

Both panthers and souths were unofficially interested not to mention cowboys was published in both 2010 and 11. earnings were on zerotackle.com dont get me wrong anasta is very good. just thought the opportunity at hand and cherrys youth would be worth grabbing.

[Roostarz]

I actually feel sorry for Anasta. He plays with passion and he tries his best but unfortunately his best is not as good as most people would like at times.

[Guest]

Backwards, if you go back to 2010 you will see that many of us were concerned about Anasta. Carney showed us how far off the mark Anasta is as a 5/8th. And Anasta showed us he didn't have the workrate of a second rower. I will grant you Anasta does show a lot of passion at times and can be an inspirational leader, but it usually takes a smack in the mouth or a pathetic refereeing decision to bring that passion out.

Maybe he needs a smack in the mouth every week?

[Guest]

Me first

[Billy Gunn]

I hate losing but I hate players who don't put in more.