Leila MacKinnon's point of view on The Roosters & Carney

[bondi-boy]

Carney is an individual that will spend his whole life looking for excuses for his failures. And unfortunately there will always be people like you gullible enough to believe every word of drivel he speaks and writes but has no intention of following through on.

NC

Not necessarily...I've seen many kids with not much idea run away to the bright lights of Kings Cross, dye their hair blue, live in squats, then mature and make wonderful parents.
Many under 25's don't have much idea.

People's intentions don't always work out 100% of the time, especially if they're 'easily-led'.
Not everyone can be perfect like the coach and the captain [not that there's anything wrong with people being perfect.]

Gullible I was for the first two years after I left high school only.
That was a long time ago.

Trouble is, last year I saw this happen:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kNRO5ViA4qg

[novice chook]

Both Brian Smith and Anasta have never claimed to be perfect. The difference between them and Carney is that both of those individuals base their decisions and actions on what is the good for the Roosters, not just themselves. Unlike the selfish individual that is Carney.

By the way BB, I never open any of the clips/attachments you put in your posts. Don't see the point. Carney's footballing talent is not in question. It's his attitide, immaturity, arrogance, selfishness, not to mention lack of commitment and discipline and willpower that I have an issue with. And will continue to do so, whether he remains at the Roosters or not. Just one of many players I've regretted being at the Roosters over the years I've supported them.

NC

[Headless Chook]

It's a big gamble if you ask me, getting rid of a fit Carney when we're down the bottom of the ladder and the playing roster will be same next year with a couple of rookies added and the same coach.
SKD now has a groin injury.

I hope for the stubborn management, stubborn coach and stubborn captain's sake their gamble pays off.

Because if it doesn't the fans will be storming the 'Bastille' and demanding that heads roll.
Take it to the bank!

Can you not pretend to speak for all our fans......I think you will find there are as many people who will support the club if they get rid of Carney if not more, than the number of fans who want him retained.