Hedger's Heroes and Zeros - Rd 12 vs Titans

[Grant Hedger]

1. Teddy 8.5 - Hero of the Week
2. Manu 4 - Zero of the Week
3. Latrell 6.5
4. Aubo 5.5
5. Fergo 6
6. Keary 8
7. Cronk 7
8. SST 7
9. Friend 6
10. Napa 7
11. Cordner 8
13. Liu 7.5
14. JWH 8

15. Tetevano 6
16. Baptiste No Rating - only got on in last 3 mins
17. Radley 8 - Him and Butcher turned the game around and got us on the front foot
18. Butcher 7

Robbo 5 - Horrible first half. The players stepped up in the 2nd for 28 unanswered points

[eddie]

Don't even understand how you rate the coach?

Bit harsh on poor Joey, he got hurt and battled on.

Maybe a bit generous with Keary today? I thought Cronk had the better game of the two halves

[Tommy Smith]

Tetevano was outstanding. His best game in Roosters colours.

Worth an 8 at least.

[RoosterFanNZ]

manu saved a try 8 mins left when we were 14 ahead they mad length of the field run and he chased all the way back and saved it, didnt have the best game but definitely not a 2. tets was great. fergo did dumbly concede that try but turned into an animal after that

[King Salvo]

A win is a win but that is what was expected - a very lethargic first half would have been costly against better sides but the Titans are not in that category luckily.

Defence - still the same errors being made and the left side and guts defence needs to really improve as better teams will exploit these areas as the Bronco's did- Lucky the Titans were denied what looked like a fair try as it could have been a 14 point deficit instead of 8 at half time - which may have ended in a different result - the sinbinning of Taylor helped even though the Chooks had drawn level up and until that stage - not many teams are scoring points against 12 player defences but Taylor is crucial to the Titans chances of winning - Roosters I thought scored 8 (press are saying 14 points) with Taylor off the field for 10 minutes.

Anyway the score

Roosters defence receives a 4 out of 10

Attack - still clunky and still wasting opportunities - need to play sets better and kicking games need to improve - Cordner passing the ball was a shock and he needs to do it more - outside backs need to get clean ball so there is still a lot to work on in this area too of their game as well as in support play/passing and offloads.

Roosters attack receives a 4 out of 10

Total score - 8 out of 20 divided by 2

Roosters receive a 4 out of 10

Robbo - still needs to get improvement from the team and individuals in all areas - errors/poor defence and attack options and penalties are still hindering the Chooks game - Better teams will take full advantage of this - Cannot be lethargic as they were in the first half and expect to win games against better teams - Hard draw in second half of season including the impact of SOO in players missing(who will replace them as depth is a major worry) and those players backing up on short turnarounds. Second half of season needs to be better as currently 7 and 5 at the half way point.






Roosters so far over all have had a 4 out of 10 season which has left then with plenty to do in the second half of the season considering they had the so called easiest draw. Would have been expecting to be at least 10 and 2 or better - so roughly 3 games or more down on where they should be at this stage of the season. They have a much harder set of 12 games coming up too in the second half of the season.

[Guest]

Radley was so good once again.

[mightyrooster]

So TR gets the blame for the first half but none of the credit for the second half? Interesting.

[Johnny73]

So TR gets the blame for the first half but none of the credit for the second half? Interesting.

Victory has many parents, failure is an orphan.

[mightyrooster]

Victory has many parents, failure is an orphan.

But the overall result was a victory. It seems to lack logic to me but there you go.

[Thirteen]

Credability lost at Fergo 6. I know he made a mistake that led to a try but his carries and quick play the balls were sensational.

[Grant Hedger]

Credability lost at Fergo 6. I know he made a mistake that led to a try but his carries and quick play the balls were sensational.

Unfortunately he makes too many errors that undo the good things - and he now does it every week. 6 is fair.

[Guest]

Credability lost at Fergo 6. I know he made a mistake that led to a try but his carries and quick play the balls were sensational.

Credability lost at Fergo 6. I know he made a mistake that led to a try but his carries and quick play the balls were sensational.

Her ran for over 200 metres as well. Again!

[Johnny73]

But the overall result was a victory. It seems to lack logic to me but there you go.

Life's a funny thing.

[Guest]

[QUOTE=Grant Hedger;n7431

Unfortunately he makes too many errors that undo the good things - and he now does it every week. 6 is fair. [/QUOTE]

Hedger how about some more effort from you? All you do is give a number. Its nothing. You need to write a few sentences for each player.

Latrell's loser of the week is Hedger. 3\10. Grant has consistently demonstrated lazy writing and has shown himself to be an unreliable spectator and even more unreliable judge. Hedger focuses on moments not matches. Generally his performance has been sub-par.

[eddie]

So TR gets the blame for the first half but none of the credit for the second half? Interesting.

I think Robbo dropped the ball that led to the stingrays first try.
Teddy gave the half time instructions?

We'll have to ask Grant how he rates Robbo every week. Perhaps he's Jason Taylor?

These ratings are a bit silly.