Linnett > All our backs bar RTS

[Guest]

I can make BS up to. JWH, Tasi, Cordner, Moga, RTS wer all signed on massive overs aswell.

Lol. Cordner wasnt bought. He is a Roosters junior. RTS was cheap as chips. He came here becuase he wanted the quickest opportunity possible to play for a pro competition. We got him cheap and remember we bought him as a schoolboy last year. Moga also a bred Roosters junio. JWH was playing NSW Cup. Tasi was a NYC player for Manly. Both were bought cheap. None were paid overs but re-siging some of these players were expensive if thats what your trying to say.

We did however pay overs on Frank Paul-Nuuasaala and Justin Carney. Carney leaves next year and FPN hopefully gets released along with Symonds whos rotting in NSW Cup along with Mose

Get back to the paddock you idiot.

Firstly, Cordner is from Old Bar or something and was a Newcastle junior.

Secondly, we payed good coin to get JWH from Manly. I think it was something like 245k a season for kid who'd only played a handful of first grade games at that stage.

Stop eating the funny coloured mushrooms out of the cow shit dopey.

[Guest]

Lol. Cordner wasnt bought. He is a Roosters junior. RTS was cheap as chips. He came here becuase he wanted the quickest opportunity possible to play for a pro competition. We got him cheap and remember we bought him as a schoolboy last year. Moga also a bred Roosters junio. JWH was playing NSW Cup. Tasi was a NYC player for Manly. Both were bought cheap. None were paid overs but re-siging some of these players were expensive if thats what your trying to say.

We did however pay overs on Frank Paul-Nuuasaala and Justin Carney. Carney leaves next year and FPN hopefully gets released along with Symonds whos rotting in NSW Cup along with Mose

Sadly I don't think Taree NSW is in the Roosters junior area... RTS was chased by several teams so i'm sure he was cheap as chip haha.

Both JWH and Tasi were highly prized signings from Manly, they rarely lose players they want to keep so i'm sure they wern't cheap.

See how I can change things around too.

Look i'll go again.

Tariq Sims was cheap because he wanted to follow Ashton up north. Kalifa Fai Fai Loa came cheap because he wanted a opprtunity in FG, something he couldn't get at the dragons because of Morris and Nightingale on the wings. Tamou came cheap because like many have said on here the roosters got rid of him because of things not associated with his onfield performances. See how easy it is to spin things. Linnett came cheap because he wanted to play outside JT or perhaps like many deluded fans on here he was behind both Moga and SKD in the pecking order....

So please someone provide me the links saying we have paid massive overs for all these young stars

[Guest]

Sadly I don't think Taree NSW is in the Roosters junior area... RTS was chased by several teams so i'm sure he was cheap as chip haha.

Both JWH and Tasi were highly prized signings from Manly, they rarely lose players they want to keep so i'm sure they wern't cheap.

See how I can change things around too.

Look i'll go again.

Tariq Sims was cheap because he wanted to follow Ashton up north. Kalifa Fai Fai Loa came cheap because he wanted a opprtunity in FG, something he couldn't get at the dragons because of Morris and Nightingale on the wings. Tamou came cheap because like many have said on here the roosters got rid of him because of things not associated with his onfield performances. See how easy it is to spin things. Linnett came cheap because he wanted to play outside JT or perhaps like many deluded fans on here he was behind both Moga and SKD in the pecking order....

So please someone provide me the links saying we have paid massive overs for all these young stars

JW-H and Tasi were victims of Manly`s salary cap from back ended contracts.
It is actually the Roosters whom rarely lose a player they want...

[Rooster_6]

So please someone provide me the links saying we have paid massive overs for all these young stars

Says the bloke who uses his iphone app as his main source for statistics then tries to claim it's as credible as Foxsports & SportsData.

Glass houses much?

[Guest]

Not my main source, I generally use nrlstats.com. Just find that searching for an individuals statistics is easier to look on there. You still havn't explained how it isn't as credible as the ones you mentioned when it does infact keep statistics and do live updates just like the others. Just because the stats I got off it doesn't suit your arguement it suddenly isn't credible.

[Rooster_6]

Not my main source, I generally use nrlstats.com. Just find that searching for an individuals statistics is easier to look on there. You still havn't explained how it isn't as credible as the ones you mentioned when it does infact keep statistics and do live updates just like the others. Just because the stats I got off it doesn't suit your arguement it suddenly isn't credible.

Probably because Foxsports is a multi billion dollar company who has a whole department dedicated to statistic collection in Rugby League. SportsData are the official providers of statistics for the NRL, every NRL club, Channel 9, Daily Telegraph, The Australian, Sydney Morning Herald, Courier Mail, Big League, RLW, etc etc.

LeagueLive are what exactly? A company who writes apple applications... enough said.

[Guest]

Probably because Foxsports is a multi billion dollar company who has a whole department dedicated to statistic collection in Rugby League. SportsData are the official providers of statistics for the NRL, every NRL club, Channel 9, Daily Telegraph, The Australian, Sydney Morning Herald, Courier Mail, Big League, RLW, etc etc.

LeagueLive are what exactly? A company who writes apple applications... enough said.

Leaguelive are exactly what their name is called, update live stats for people who download the app. You think they would be slack on that so that people no longer download their apps and update them? Thats how they make their money just like the others. They are doing their job, by providing stats and live updates just like the rest of them.

[Rooster_6]

Leaguelive are exactly what their name is called, update live stats for people who download the app. You think they would be slack on that so that people no longer download their apps and update them? Thats how they make their money just like the others. They are doing their job, by providing stats and live updates just like the rest of them.

Well someone's being slack... is it Foxsports or LeagueLive?

Geeez I dunnoooo.....

[Guest]

So Big League has Linnett at 12 linebreaks just like LeagueLive where as Foxsports on the link in the other thread has him at 20 linebreaks. Are you now going to discredit Big League the ''official'' magazine of the NRL? Haha.

Derp derp Derp.

[Rooster_6]

I was never arguing Linnett's stats, stay on topic your point was that SKD had ONLY made 4 linebreaks. The NRL's official statitics have him Kane Linnett on 12 linebreaks fwiw.

Just on you comment that SKD only has 4 linebreaks... in 2 minutes of video search I already found 5

http://www.nrl.com/Video/2012SmartRe...od=2&time=1205

http://www.nrl.com/Video/2012SmartRe...iod=1&time=227

http://www.nrl.com/Video/2012SmartRe...iod=1&time=873

http://www.nrl.com/Video/2012SmartRe...od=2&time=2415

http://www.nrl.com/Video/2012SmartRe...iod=1&time=287

[Guest]

Anasta has been complete rubbish for most of his time here, other than 2010 we've not had a half.

[Guest]

I was never arguing Linnett's stats, stay on topic your point was that SKD had ONLY made 4 linebreaks. The NRL's official statitics have him Kane Linnett on 12 linebreaks fwiw.

Just on you comment that SKD only has 4 linebreaks... in 2 minutes of video search I already found 5

http://www.nrl.com/Video/2012SmartRe...od=2&time=1205

http://www.nrl.com/Video/2012SmartRe...iod=1&time=227

http://www.nrl.com/Video/2012SmartRe...iod=1&time=873

http://www.nrl.com/Video/2012SmartRe...od=2&time=2415

http://www.nrl.com/Video/2012SmartRe...iod=1&time=287

My arguement has always been that LeagueLive is a reliable source to me and stating what I read on that app. You just didn't like what it had said about SKD. So you try to discredit LeagueLive. Now that it has been shown to have the same number that Big League does in terms of linebreaks for Linnett, you are the one that decides to change topic. Ahh so you see 5 Linebreaks thats a big difference to 4 which was said on LeagueLive. Nearly as big a difference of 12 (LeagueLive) and 20 (Foxsports) for Linnett in terms of linebreaks. Wasn't Foxsports one of the sources you were pushing to be more reliable???

BTW even Big League has SKD at 8 or less linebreaks for the season. Foxsports have him at 9 linebreaks for the year.

So using these two players LeagueLive does infact seem to be a fairly reliable source as on average they are closer to the mark of the ''Official'' NRL magazine due to the big difference in number for Linnett

[Rooster_6]

My arguement has always been that LeagueLive is a reliable source to me and stating what I read on that app. You just didn't like what it had said about SKD. So you try to discredit LeagueLive. Now that it has been shown to have the same number that Big League does in terms of linebreaks for Linnett, you are the one that decides to change topic. Ahh so you see 5 Linebreaks thats a big difference to 4 which was said on LeagueLive. Nearly as big a difference of 12 (LeagueLive) and 20 (Foxsports) for Linnett in terms of linebreaks. Wasn't Foxsports one of the sources you were pushing to be more reliable???

You argued that LeagueLive was just as credible as SportsData & Foxsports, that's what I was arguing against. I wasn't comparing stats I was debating which organisation was more credible, I gave up though because you refuse to state any facts about why LeagueLive is as credible source as SportsData & Foxsports. Just that they share some similar stats (a very small sample size at that).

BTW even Big League has SKD at 8 or less linebreaks for the season. Foxsports have him at 9 linebreaks for the year.

So using these two players LeagueLive does infact seem to be a fairly reliable source as on average they are closer to the mark of the ''Official'' NRL magazine due to the big difference in number for Linnett

Back to my original argument that SKD making 4 linebreaks was a fallacy, let me re-quote myself because you seem incapable of reading.

"in 2 minutes of video search I already found 5"

I never said 5 was all I could find, 5 was all I needed to find to prove that the stat was incorrect.

[Guest]

You argued that LeagueLive was just as credible as SportsData & Foxsports, that's what I was arguing against. I wasn't comparing stats I was debating which organisation was more credible, I gave up though because you refuse to state any facts about why LeagueLive is as credible source as SportsData & Foxsports. Just that they share some similar stats (a very small sample size at that).



Back to my original argument that SKD making 4 linebreaks was a fallacy, let me re-quote myself because you seem incapable of reading.

"in 2 minutes of video search I already found 5"

I never said 5 was all I could find, 5 was all I needed to find to prove that the stat was incorrect.

I did state facts you derp. LeagueLive came up with stats on the 2 players closer to Big League then what Foxsports did. LeagueLive and Big League both had Linnett at 12 linebreaks while Foxsports was a mile off with 20. Are you now going to say that the ''official'' magazine of the NRL doesn't have credible statistics?

Yes I see that and I told you that even Big League had him at 8 or less linebreaks while Foxsports had him at 9. So i'll repeat it again, over the 2 guys LeagueLive has been closer on average then Foxsports in relation to linebreaks for the 2 guys compared to the ''official'' magazine of the NRL.

[Guest]

So Big League has Linnett at 12 linebreaks just like LeagueLive where as Foxsports on the link in the other thread has him at 20 linebreaks. Are you now going to discredit Big League the ''official'' magazine of the NRL? Haha.

Derp derp Derp.

Do you even go for the Cowboys or are you only going for them because they have Johnathan Thurston, Matt Bowen and Travis Norton