Isaac

[Johnny Tobin]

Tweet from NRL Physio that he is out for 2-3 weeks:

https://twitter.com/nrlphysio/status/859763822277439489

I suppose that means he could be back after Parra game.

[Thirteen]

I'm so relieved. YEH RIGHT!

[Roosterfarian]

Not a fan 13?

[Johnny Tobin]

I don't get the Isaac bashing.

[Tommy Smith]

Isaac is Mr Consistent.

Love his footwork before the line and that pearler of a short ball for Pearce's try in the Anzac clash.

Unfortunately he's had an injury disrupted start to the season which hasn't allowed him to build any momentum.

[ROC181]

I don't get the Isaac bashing.

Don't either...He's a hard worker but is not a prop. He is great off the bench. I think Trent has asked him to change a few things to cover for the loss of Moa and isn't working. I did like how he took Burgess off though. There are far bigger problems IMO, than Issac.

[Parkway_Drive]

Liu has had to play a different role this year and also had a number of injuries. He is a solid player with some skill. Not a god of thunder style of front rower.

I wonder if Lindsay Collins will get called up into the top 17?

[Easts75]

Liu has had to play a different role this year and also had a number of injuries. He is a solid player with some skill. Not a god of thunder style of front rower.

I wonder if Lindsay Collins will get called up into the top 17?

From the very little I've seen of Collins he has looked outstanding and a genuine first grade prospect. Hopefully gets a run over Origin period

[Guest]

I don't get the Isaac bashing.

he isn't flashy so most people can't see his value

[Kelby]

Liu has had to play a different role this year and also had a number of injuries. He is a solid player with some skill. Not a god of thunder style of front rower.

I wonder if Lindsay Collins will get called up into the top 17?

I hope so. He has been playing well in reggies.

[Thirteen]

Not a fan 13?

No mate. My 5 year old is more agro than this bloke. I want angry and mean front rowers.

[Lydon]

Good player but too nice,we need another nut out there!

[roostersrule2]

Liu is a champion.

He's the prototype modern day lock. Big motor, good footwork and good passing ability. He's probably the most underrated player in the game.

[Waylander]

Liu hurt his foot in the warm up to the Warriors game. The Injury report on the Roosters app says he'll miss "3 weeks of football" but that may not have taken the Rep Round into account.

I like him, and think he is ideal as a lock rotation with SST. I'd prefer a more damaging big body in the prop rotation. Collins in taller but no heavier than Liu. He seems to have a bit more mongrel though, and that's worth a few kilo's. He will probably fill out a little more over time. At 194cm he could certainly carry more than his profile stated 106kg.

[mightyrooster]

A very underrated player on here. He will be missed. I'm not a fan of him at prop though. He nneds to stay at lock from the bench.