FFS Stop it

[stephenj]

he should have had 10 in the bin!

[Thirteen]

We went into the game with wrong attitude and that affects our defence. We are the best team. Only our attitude or lack of can beat us.

[liver1971]

The question is ,if we didnt score from toupo's kick ahead would it have been a penalty try ?
Either way some people have a short memory ,does last years grand final ring a bell ?we didnt get the bin
No player is sinbinned in those situations where the attacking team has scored points[whether a penaly try or not] , rightly or wrongly

[Guest]

Need a like button!

[Guest]

well said omr.

I have a question is why wasn't reynold not sent off for tackling touppo without the ball. its a professional foul.

You stick to pruning the hedges and let those that know RL speak..

[Roostarz]

a profession foul is just that. it is no different to a shoulder charge or high tackle. the rules say 10 in the bin for a professional foul. regardless of a try or not. if it was a shoulder charge which knock out toupo. would that be a send off or just a gggeeeeeez that would hurt,,,,keep playing.

In that case why wasn't Aubo sent to the bin in the Grand Final?

Short/biased memories.

[Matty_C]

We went into the game with wrong attitude and that affects our defense. We are the best team. Only our attitude or lack of can beat us.

I agree.
We are the best team.
It's a weird thing to say when you lose by 20 but I thought we looked like a very classy outfit playing well below their best, and they looked like a good
outfit playing to their best.
Whilst this served Souths well last night, you would expect this will be rectified pretty quickly.
To the poster earlier the commented on JWH. I agree, he is too big at the moment. Whoever put him in that diet in the off season got it very wrong.

[Guest]

I think you will find he put himself on that diet. Heard an interview with him I think at the wcc, said he really enjoys his time off in the offseason, loves his food.

[Guest]

ffs.
Why is the word "orgasm" associated with watching football??????????????????????????

I reckon I love the Roosters more than the average Eddie, but there are limits "ppl"

[Juggler]

well said omr.

I have a question is why wasn't reynold not sent off for tackling touppo without the ball. its a professional foul.

Because the end result was the try to jennings. It was, at the time, the greatest advantage. Remember that Aubusson wasn't binned in the GF either. Reynolds was warned by the ref that if we didn't score, he gets 10.

[Juggler]

a profession foul is just that. it is no different to a shoulder charge or high tackle. the rules say 10 in the bin for a professional foul. regardless of a try or not.

Actually, you're wrong. There are no hard and fast rules about the Sin Bin. It is referee's discretion.

[Juggler]

Because he plays for Souths, the teachers' pets?

Cause we scored.

[Guest]

I didn't get to the game & I haven't been on here or spoken to any Rooster fans but any suggestion of dropping anyone is just off with the fairies stuff. We are in the same position this year as we were in last year. South's beat us in Rd 1 last year as they have this year. We will still be in the top 4.

By the way South's are a top top team, I tip them to win the comp, lets see how the other 14 teams go against them before we drop any Roosters players.

[Guest]

I didn't get to the game & I haven't been on here or spoken to any Rooster fans but any suggestion of dropping anyone is just off with the fairies stuff. We are in the same position this year as we were in last year. South's beat us in Rd 1 last year as they have this year. We will still be in the top 4.

By the way South's are a top top team, I tip them to win the comp, lets see how the other 14 teams go against them before we drop any Roosters players.

The new ruck rules don't suit our game or roster, Its all about size and speed in 014. Team balance is a thing of the past!

[roosterproud]

Because the end result was the try to jennings. It was, at the time, the greatest advantage. Remember that Aubusson wasn't binned in the GF either. Reynolds was warned by the ref that if we didn't score, he gets 10.

aubo gave away a 8 pointer

I am a ref. fao and coach....professional foul is what it is ...send off all day long