Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Perrett and Mitchell got me thinking...

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Perrett and Mitchell got me thinking...

    Just thinking... why do NRL players have to stick to their contracts and what are the ramifications if they don't?

    When I did contract work I had an agreement with my employer - he could sack me any time and I could walk any time. There was a gentlemanly agreement that we wouldn't screw each other over but people did that occasionally and it was part of life.

    S*cked for the company if a frontline worker just pulled out suddenly, but you'd deal with it. Guys got reputations for pulling out suddenly and consequently would struggle to find work.

    Why is the NRL any different? I sorta feel they should have 2 types of players:
    1) People who have ongoing contracts... say 10 years with the club. These guys would earn salaries and get bonuses based on form. Less money but more safety for both the player and the club.
    2) Contractors who are pretty well freelance. This would allow for example SBW to sign with us as the highest paid player. If we don't like him after 3 weeks we can punt him and free up our salary cap INSTANTLY. Could make it interesting if there was a pool of contractors who changed clubs regularly and were on top dollar (with the knowledge that if they aren't winning games, they will be in trouble.

    SBW could contract... Get his top dollar, box and play union in Japan, but if he stinks, neither party is obliged to hold onto their part of the deal. These players could train by themselves (or with te team they are contracted to) and offer specialist skills at a higher rate rather than commitment/development. Older injury hit players could do this too - say they don't think they can last a season, but are still fit enough to make an impact off the bench for a few games while somebody is out injured.

    Injury hit teams and under-performing teams could benefit as well for example if they were to sign somebody to specifically replace an injured player until they are fit again.

  • #2
    Ian Schubert is trying to get that post deleted. It would make policing the cap almost impossible.
    Teams as much as players want stability in the players also.

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by Soup View Post
      Ian Schubert is trying to get that post deleted. It would make policing the cap almost impossible.
      Teams as much as players want stability in the players also.
      I reckon some players just want $$$ and some teams NEED talent to fill urgent gaps.

      Comment


      • #4
        Same thing that happened with Sbw

        Comment


        • #5
          This is getting ridiculous to the point of that soon a player playing for one team can go off at halftime, get a contract faxed to him and play for the opposition in the second half.

          They need to stop this mid-season transfer shit.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by John View Post
            This is getting ridiculous to the point of that soon a player playing for one team can go off at halftime, get a contract faxed to him and play for the opposition in the second half.

            They need to stop this mid-season transfer shit.
            I don't have an issue with it, it's great for players who are looking to get a shot at first grade and for players who are uncontracted, on the flip side it's great for clubs who are struggling for depth due to injuries. The issue here isn't the Mid-season transfers it's the poor communication between Perrett and the club, someone's obviously said something they shouldn't have or Perrett and his management team have mis-read a situation.

            The game is better off for having the likes of Inu, Mason & Gagai in first grade rather than rotting away in park footy or pissing off to another code.
            Last edited by Rooster_6; 06-20-2012, 02:50 AM.

            Comment


            • #7
              LOL John.

              Chook.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by John View Post
                This is getting ridiculous to the point of that soon a player playing for one team can go off at halftime, get a contract faxed to him and play for the opposition in the second half.

                They need to stop this mid-season transfer shit.
                good shit john
                1911 1912 1913 1923 1935 1936 1937 1940 1945 1974 1975 2002 2013 2018 2019 2020

                Comment


                • #9
                  ism sounds like willie mason to me?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    It's getting to be like professional sport in the states.

                    I was living in Canada in the 90s when the Bluejays won their first World Series. Ricky Henderson signed with the Jays from New York a couple of games out from the playoffs, played a major role in their World Series win and then left the club straight after - really weird but we seem to be going the way of the mid season trade becoming par for the course.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by John View Post
                      This is getting ridiculous to the point of that soon a player playing for one team can go off at halftime, get a contract faxed to him and play for the opposition in the second half.

                      They need to stop this mid-season transfer shit.
                      What a ripper John.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by John View Post
                        This is getting ridiculous to the point of that soon a player playing for one team can go off at halftime, get a contract faxed to him and play for the opposition in the second half.

                        They need to stop this mid-season transfer shit.
                        I believe it has already happened in the US seriously. I cant remember the fine details but I did hear something about that happening.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          It's all professional whether we like it or not. Most guys get about 10 years to make some serious cash (which TBH isn't THAT much as many can make more in back office low pressure jobs without the limelight.)

                          There's no point beating around the bush, particularly if you're solid but will never get rep bonuses...etc. Think somebody like Mitchell... There's probably a number of forum members making more than him who nobody's ever heard of. They can also keep their jobs for 20+ years, whereas for many it's footy...then what? Gotta make the most outta it.

                          Stability will come for the more likeable players and guys like SBW will make a fark load being the guy everybody likes to hate... just like work. My boss is a career man who employs specialist contractors on twice his pay. The business world is like that!

                          My reckoning is that players on $100-$200k will benefit the most though. $100k is PEANUTS for all the publicity and performance expectations put on an NRL player. I wouldn't put up with all the scrutiny, training and BS for that.

                          ---

                          Loyalty will always exist, but so will money hungry disloyal b@stards, and battlers on lower/middle incomes who want to get ahead rather than playing for the Jets every weekend and getting nowhere when another club needs them in FG.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            This SBW contract is designed to suit SBW. The only positive sign I see at this stage is that so many of you are excited by his arrival. If that turns into bums on seats, and we can get an atmosphere that will intimidate the opposition and referees, that would be a positive.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              SBW;

                              No RU in Japan.
                              No boxing.

                              Concentrate 100% on playing RL for us, or no contract with us should he be getting.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X