Mini's postional play is crap!

[Guest]

Last night he was up in the defensive line when he should have been back [dogs scored], when the Dogs played right he was left[ dogs scored], shit on line cover defence[dogs scored more], cost us 4 tries last night! wake up Mini!

[BarnstormingBlockbustin']

There wasn't much mini could do about most of their try's. Pez was caught out all night by a player that's been in 2nd grade.
More like Wake up Perret

[Guest]

More like what a well coached Bulldogs side.

[Chook Norris]

The only one i would truly fault him for is Stagg's try through the grubber kick

that one was pretty bad. Mini was not even close and read it terribly wrong

[Guest]

What about the one where Ennis caught Mini up in the Defensive line and Kicked through,[ they kicked through on a number of occasions because Minmi wasn't back], it was regatherd and lead to a try. He was up in the D line for up to 3 tackles at times, if he keeps it up other teams will exploit it. Good fullbacks save tries by being there to hold up tries, Mini most times is nowhere near the ball when teams are attacking our line.

[ROC181]

Mini wouldn't be there if Smith would stop him. I'm sure that someone like Bellamy would tell Mini to stop getting involved as much as he does. I don't recall Mini being like that before Smith came as a coach.

[Juggler]

There wasn't much mini could do about most of their try's. Pez was caught out all night by a player that's been in 2nd grade.
More like Wake up Perret

Sorry, who was fullback... Mini or Perrett? How was the try before half time Perrett's fault?

[BUDDY]

Sorry, who was fullback... Mini or Perrett? How was the try before half time Perrett's fault?

If he didn't let the previous one in we wouldn't have kicked off.

[BarnstormingBlockbustin']

Sorry, who was fullback... Mini or Perrett? How was the try before half time Perrett's fault?

I did say most try's. Are you talking about the try when peni slid for the ball and 'apparently' tore his hamstring? That was def not minis fault.

[Guest]

i read a lot of post but this one is your best .LOL

Last night he was up in the defensive line when he should have been back [dogs scored], when the Dogs played right he was left[ dogs scored], shit on line cover defence[dogs scored more], cost us 4 tries last night! wake up Mini!

[Juggler]

If he didn't let the previous one in we wouldn't have kicked off.

And if we had driven them back in the first tackle of the game they would have dropped out.

Or if we had tackled like the demons of hell, the Dogs would never have been in a position to put up a bomb.

FFS let's bring a bit of sanity & logic back into this. Oh wait. This is the Chookpen.

[BUDDY]

And if we had driven them back in the first tackle of the game they would have dropped out.

Or if we had tackled like the demons of hell, the Dogs would never have been in a position to put up a bomb.

FFS let's bring a bit of sanity & logic back into this. Oh wait. This is the Chookpen.

It sure is the chookpen and plenty can't see sarcasm if it smacks them in the face.

[Juggler]

I did say most try's. Are you talking about the try when peni slid for the ball and 'apparently' tore his hamstring? That was def not minis fault.

Mini can get lazy with his positional play - and i'm including the early to mid 2000s. Last night, he CHOSE to stay in the defensive line for up to three tackles. He showed little urgency to get back until Ennis kicked for the try before half time.

To blame Perrett alone for all the other tries is unfair. Some blame certainly, especially the first. But he was not wholly to blame. If people wish to blame him entirely they can, however, they show little understanding of what is required in defence on the wing.

[Guest]

i read a lot of post but this one is your best .LOL

LOL, Thanks bro! not as good as those you tube clips though..

[BarnstormingBlockbustin']

it's hard to say if he CHOSE to stay up. It looked more like a tact by smith to try limit the bankstown mutts forward packs quick passing up the middle.

To blame Minichello alone for all the other tries is unfair. Some blame certainly, especially the first. But he was not wholly to blame. If people wish to blame him entirely they can, however, they show little understanding of what is required in defending from the back.

You said it