While we are at it. The over rated players of 2021

[Johnny Tobin]

CockNBalls at the Dogs isn’t rated so he can’t be overrated.

Wighton has been my most overrated for years.

[BraveTheWorld]

Off the top of my head, Wighton, Tino Fa'asuamaleaui, Gutherson, Arrow, Kikau and lowkey Munster, even though he can be the best player in the world on his day.

[Cockadoodledoo]

I thought someone who was overrated had to be rated, not sure why Sharon Woods or Bob Marley are being included.

Nathan Brown (not the coach). He is supposed to be a tough guy but I think he has only played well against the Roosters once, in the all the years I have seen him play and that is because he rode on the back of RCG's coat tails. Mitchell Moses, downhill skier. Gutho, another flat track bully, bit of a theme here. Nick Cotric, absolutely hopeless at the Dogs before getting injured.

[bondi.boy]

Off the top of my head, Wighton, Tino Fa'asuamaleaui, Gutherson, Arrow, Kikau and lowkey Munster, even though he can be the best player in the world on his day.

Kikau? He has an unusual hairdo.
And an unusual knack of scoring multiple tries against us and winning those games.

[trewhella]

probably better to be titled players who didn't live up to the hype or those who have gone down hill

• Ash Taylor
• Anthony Milford
• Brody Croft
• Luke Brooks
• Curtis Scott
• Euan Aitken
• Esan Marsters
• David Klemmer
• Dylan Napa

To name a few

solid list

[Kingbilly]

forgot Whiighton, he is probably the winner

[BraveTheWorld]

Kikau? He has an unusual hairdo.
And an unusual knack of scoring multiple tries against us and winning those games.

Absolute gun player on his day, but definitely can be lazy and isn't as consistent as I would like him to be, if he were in my team.

[rented tracksuit]

Copley

Beat me to it.

[rented tracksuit]

probably better to be titled players who didn't live up to the hype or those who have gone down hill

• Ash Taylor
• Anthony Milford
• Brody Croft
• Luke Brooks
• Curtis Scott
• Euan Aitken
• Esan Marsters
• David Klemmer
• Dylan Napa

To name a few

Croft is absolutely shithouse!

[GT3370]

Croft is absolutely shithouse!

There has been a lot of really good half prospects in the last decade that never lived up to the hype.Croft , Mortimer ,Watson,Flanagan and so many more .Tough gig this NRL .

[rented tracksuit]

There has been a lot of really good half prospects in the last decade that never lived up to the hype.Croft , Mortimer ,Watson,Flanagan and so many more .Tough gig this NRL .

TBH, nothing was really expected of the others like there was of the Cronk understudy.

[Cyril Snodgrass III]

Fumbles Ikuvalu

[Spirit of 66]

Anasta

[SupermanSupportsEasts4Eva]

Luke Brooks.

Tigpies lost Teddy, Pap, JAC, Moses and Benji, yet kept this guy.... no wonder they keep coming 9th

[bondi.boy]

Absolute gun player on his day, but definitely can be lazy and isn't as consistent as I would like him to be, if he were in my team.

True.
But I hope we have a plan to stop him this weekend.
Kikau v Walker ..Kikau's eyes would light up.
Think I saw Liu and SST defending at right assisting Walker against the Eels.
Hope that continues against the Panthers.