While we are at it. The over rated players of 2021

[trewhella]

Snoop dog on the wing for the dogs is incredibly bad.
not a first grader…..
Sharon Woods at the Sharks…..so ineffective for an ex origin player
Steven Crichton at the riff…..talent but lazy lazy lazy

[Rooster90]

What has Jai Arrow ever done besides having a hot (ex) missus?

certainly not enough to warrant a $800k per year deal.

Even when at the Titans he was either injured every second game or had a shit haircut.

[TeddyGoat]

Can't go past 'king' gutho and reed mahoney personally.

[The Brain]

What has Jai Arrow ever done besides having a hot (ex) missus?

certainly not enough to warrant a $800k per year deal.

Even when at the Titans he was either injured every second game or had a shit haircut.

was not his ex it was a hooker

[The Brain]

Lam

[trewhella]

Lachlan is another example of a switched on father who knows how the NRL works and tutors his kid from a young age in rugby league but doesn’t have the natural gifts to back it up
Good on Adrian and Shane Flanagan for knowing how to give their kids a running start. No shade from me at all on that.
Both Kyle and Lachlan have earned great cash and I hope love playing the game…….but agreed, I don’t see long term first grade careers in either player

[Rooster90]

was not his ex it was a hooker

I'm talking about Taylah Cannon who is now his ex due to said hooker.

[The Brain]

I'm talking about Taylah Cannon who is now his ex due to said hooker.

hookerfest 2021

[GT3370]

Copley

[Easts75]

Mbye...his whole career

[Kingbilly]

Kikau like a few of his ritth mates rides the coat tails of the real talent there.

Staggs, I know he hasn't played much but he is one of the worst players I have ever seen. Just plain can not defend, positionally or physically.
Actually most of of the Broncos are crap

[King Salvo]

probably better to be titled players who didn't live up to the hype or those who have gone down hill

• Ash Taylor
• Anthony Milford
• Brody Croft
• Luke Brooks
• Curtis Scott
• Euan Aitken
• Esan Marsters
• David Klemmer
• Dylan Napa

To name a few

[Roosterfarian]

Copley

Gold!

[ism22]

No surprises from me (I think I've shared my opinions quite frequently). To me over-rated doesn't mean somebody's shyte (some people read it that way). To me it means somebody who is generally referred to as being an absolute wizard (i.e. they are 'rated') but that rating seems somewhat gratuitous.

As such, the players I identify are all considered top notch (by somebody at least) and commentators will tell you they are dominating every aspect of a game (IMO regularly this is happening in an alternative reality to the game I'm watching). I'm not saying they are shyte... I'm merely speculating that they have significantly less impact on their team's results than they regularly get credit for.

So my list?
- Harry Grant - I've had numerous rants about this so wonMt say much more. He plays 15 minutes each half for a team that rarely has to dig deep during that period (i.e. the game's usually over by that point).
- Ponga - I don't think he's up to the same standard as guys like Teddy, Trbo, Pap, RTS [and Slater]. He's good but I reckon Knights would be top-8 if his form matched his salary/reputation.
- Toho - TBH I thought he got found out in Origin 3. His combo with the Penrith halves was important but I dunno... I reckon there's much better wingers out there.
- Wighton - He's been around the traps a bit ay... fullback, centre, halfback...etc. I dunno, to me his attitude has never been that of a winner and most of his career has involved getting i to trouble, under-performing, injuring himself doing stupid stuff (e.g. drunken trampolining) and wasting salary cap space in Canberra. He had a single good season in 2019 when Canberra were allowed to blatantly cheat by doing 5-man strips. Since then he's done very little but remains rusted onto rep teams at every level. Again, I think there are better alternatives out there!
- Milford - I'll get a spray for this but WTF did Souffs release Reynolds for Milford? To me Milford sits in the same category as Wighton... both jacked around in Canberra and have been considered wizards all along. However, in what parallel universe has Milford achieved anything? He always seems to get signed as a marquee player so that he can then play like he's there on minimum wage to make up the numbers. I don't get what people see in him!

[Bahrain Rooster]

probably better to be titled players who didn't live up to the hype or those who have gone down hill

• Ash Taylor
• Anthony Milford
• Brody Croft
• Luke Brooks
• Curtis Scott
• Euan Aitken
• Esan Marsters
• David Klemmer
• Dylan Napa

To name a few

Klemmer is a victim of the set restart rule along with Taumalolo. That type of player is nearly obsolete these days.