That Keary decision at the end

[Bruce Pickett]

Who the fark is the 9 commentator? Deathriding us all game and saying Keary was offside? Replay once only. Slater try off Lockyear SOO anyone? It went from potential penalty try to us to penalty for them??
I'm totally confused.

I hate this 6 again.

Correct me if I'm wrong. We won it 3-2, but each one of ours was on 1st tackle and I know at least one of theirs was on 3rd if not both?

To hell with this crap rule.

[elo]

Keary had a grounded foot slightly in front of JoMo's kick.....it should have never been sent up to the vidiot however, that's not what it's there for.

[RoosterFanNZ]

i dont understand why the ref called a no try when there was no try scoring action happening just to check the offside.

[Mad_Rabid_Rooster]

Keary had a grounded foot slightly in front of JoMo's kick.....it should have never been sent up to the vidiot however, that's not what it's there for.

I agree with this.

[Jacks Fur Coat]

That 9 commentor was soooo obvious with his riding home the Raiders. At least Freddy was good, calling out the BS and giving us due credit for the past 3 years.

[rented tracksuit]

I’m still not convinced he was offside at all. I think the was a shot from another angle that looked like was dead inline or just behind the kicking foot. Needless to say, they didn’t look at that one again but focused on the one that looked like he was just in front. Marginal at best and as said before, shouldn’t be that video ref is there for as no try was attempted to have been scored.

[BUDDY]

I thought Keary was offside.
but about half a metre less offside than Luai last week and Walker the week before.
That is why the subjectiveness of the bunker makes every decision exciting.
FFS

[SupermanSupportsEasts4Eva]

The right call was made.... but Klien had no business sending it up to be checked. Obviously no try. The Klown needed to make the call on field

[Johnny Tobin]

Why didn’t he send Morris up for possible penalty try? We should have received a penalty and probably win the game.

[Danish]

He was clearly offside

little bit rich for anyone to get annoyed at a ref bending the rule book to ensure a correct ruling was made.

frankly I’m much more interested in Keary’s decision making for the other 79 minutes than that one

[Team Evil]

I had no issue with the off side call but if he could ask for a replay for an off side then why not when our winger gets his head taken off!
I just hate the inconstancy.

[King Salvo]

He was clearly offside

little bit rich for anyone to get annoyed at a ref bending the rule book to ensure a correct ruling was made.

frankly I’m much more interested in Keary’s decision making for the other 79 minutes than that one

According to fox keary anf flanno were ordinary

[chopstiks]

The time they spent trying to deny Joey Manu, its no wonder we got nothing else.

[roostermcgregor]

Yep, ref and bunker were desperately trying to find fault with the Manu Try.
Morris got collared not once , but twice by CNK around the head. Second one should have been penalty try , or penalty at the very least, as JT has commented.
If you look at the video footage, Morris' whole body leaves the ground on both occasions, as he is caught around the neck.
How obvious is it that its an illegal tackle? But Klein doesn't rule it that way, as he knows we are on a roll, and another set of six on their line, we were certain to score and go to the front on the scoreboard .
The NRL , Cummins, Sutton & Klein had an agenda, they achieved it - they have F*cked off the Roosters because everyone else wanted it that way.

[Andrew Walker]

i dont understand why the ref called a no try when there was no try scoring action happening just to check the offside.

It is called selectively abusing the use of the video referee None of us have crustal balls or can see the future so none of us can say we would have scored had we got that repeat set Unlike every ****wit last year with the 6 again and in 2004 at the end of Cowboys game when they should have got a penalty, who somehow all decided that tried would have been scored had the decision gone the other teams way