Hypothetical-Prefer to Win last night JWH rubbed out for 2 weeks Vs current position?

[The Axe]

Tough one

[Sizzle]

Prefer to win for sure mate. JWH has been shit recently and as much as we hate to admit it he is becoming a huge liability in finals for us. If we win last night I'd be locking us in for the 3peat with a much easier draw, now we have to do it the hard way. The way Lindsay performed last night would make me even question if JWH still deserves to start...

[NorfolkStreetKid]

Prefer to win for sure mate. JWH has been shit recently and as much as we hate to admit it he is becoming a huge liability in finals for us. If we win last night I'd be locking us in for the 3peat with a much easier draw, now we have to do it the hard way. The way Lindsay performed last night would make me even question if JWH still deserves to start...

There is no limit to the idiocy posted on this site.

[Mickie Lane]

I would rather of won & JWH rubbed out for 2 weeks because the 3 times we have won the comp under Robbo JWH has been suspended during that year.

[Sizzle]

There is no limit to the idiocy posted on this site.

He has been shit lol. We've been getting dominated in the forwards the past few weeks. I can't sit here and gas up any of our middle forwards besides maybe Lindsay. If they aren't winning the forward battle then they arent doing there jobs, especially JWH who is notorious for over powering the opposition forwards through his aggression

not to mention his consistent penalties which become extremely costly in finals.

[Easts75]

Win for sure

JWH hasnt been shit........but notnfar off it. I can't remember when he carried the ball with venom, just looks old and gassed at the moment

[Steakface]

I think it's clear JWH has been carrying an injury / injuries. He has a permanent sternum injury too don't forget.

I wouldn't be against seeing Collins & SST start with JWH from the bench, but it won't happen.

[Rooster_6]

He has been shit lol. We've been getting dominated in the forwards the past few weeks. I can't sit here and gas up any of our middle forwards besides maybe Lindsay. If they aren't winning the forward battle then they arent doing there jobs, especially JWH who is notorious for over powering the opposition forwards through his aggression

not to mention his consistent penalties which become extremely costly in finals.

He has been below his level of ability but to say he has been shit is an exaggeration. He's still comfortably in the best 4 props at the club.

[Rooster_6]

I think it's clear JWH has been carrying an injury / injuries. He has a permanent sternum injury too don't forget.

I wouldn't be against seeing Collins & SST start with JWH from the bench, but it won't happen.

Disagree I like the impact Collins provides off the bench.

[Mad_Rabid_Rooster]

I would prefer the win - a guaranteed week 3 start - any day of the week. Lindsay deserves to start over JWH for mine.

[NorfolkStreetKid]

I think last week in the Souths game, JWH made over 50 tackles and over 150 metres. More likely than not he is carrying an injury. He is a starting prop in any team in the comp, and Lindsay is better suited off the bench. To say JWH has been shit or close to it is absolute dribble..... but fits in nicely with so much other dribble on this site.