Pearce > Cronk

[Maxy Walker]

Cronk did a nice 40-20. What else? A bunch of bombs that went straight to the fullback. Not much else.

We are in danger of becoming the transit lounge again.

[Flipper Hands]

Haha Maxy. You are either a brave man, or a brilliant troll. /popcorn

[Arties Pie]

As well as a 40/20 he got a repeat set which was something Pearce can't do... So for mine Cronk > Pearce.

[Maxy Walker]

Haha Maxy. You are either a brave man, or a brilliant troll. /popcorn

Nah. I’m serious. Cronk is a straight up and down plodder who has been made to look good in the Melbourne structure.

Pearce is a far more dynamic player.

Our worst fears were realised today.

[easts4eva]

Hard to soar like an eagle when you're in with the Turkey's

[Louis N]

Nah. I’m serious. Cronk is a straight up and down plodder who has been made to look good in the Melbourne structure.

Pearce is a far more dynamic player.

Our worst fears were realised today.

ROFLMAO You obviously have never watched a State of Origin game.

[stringaz]

I'm not going to weigh in on cronk yet, don't totally disagree with Maxy tho, but the premise chucked around on here about him lifting the team 20% ala SBW I'm not sold on

Friend can be his worst enemy

[eddie]

Cronk had a good game today.
We can't expect him to beat teams on his pat malone.

[Maxy Walker]

ROFLMAO You obviously have never watched a State of Origin game.

ROFLMAO at you if you think origin has anything to do with it.

[Louis N]

ROFLMAO at you if you think origin has anything to do with it.

Eat this for dinner
Dally M Player of the Year: 2013, 2016
Dally M Halfback of the Year: 2006, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2016
Clive Churchill Medal: 2012
Rugby League World Golden Boot Award: 2016

All on Melbourne structures. Pull the other one.

[Flipper Hands]

Nah. I’m serious. Cronk is a straight up and down plodder who has been made to look good in the Melbourne structure.

Pearce is a far more dynamic player.

Our worst fears were realised today.

I thought he was decent today behind a plodding pack. I got pounded last year for voicing similar reservations about Cronk.

He may be no saviour, but I'm going to enjoy seeing if he is.

[Flipper Hands]

Eat this for dinner
Dally M Player of the Year: 2013, 2016
Dally M Halfback of the Year: 2006, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2016
Clive Churchill Medal: 2012
Rugby League World Golden Boot Award: 2016

All on Melbourne structures. Pull the other one.

I think the point is, he isn't in Kansas anymore.

[Maxy Walker]

Eat this for dinner
Dally M Player of the Year: 2013, 2016
Dally M Halfback of the Year: 2006, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2016
Clive Churchill Medal: 2012
Rugby League World Golden Boot Award: 2016

All on Melbourne structures. Pull the other one.

Yes, all achieved within Melbourne structure, more or less, with Cam Smith at hooker.

[eddie]

Yes, all achieved within Melbourne structure, more or less, with Cam Smith at hooker.

Pearce would've torn that structure apart.

[Gary Worthless]

Thought Cronk was our second best player today after Fergo. Cronk must have been wondering what the hell has he signed up for with all of our stupid penalties and errors which we fans of course are completely used to.