Todd Carney - worst defender in the nrl

[Guest]

That's funny.

Mini is last century's news and you won't hear a bad word against him.

Carney is playing well below par but he is many times more effective than your boy.

Oh man, where do you start with the Count.

I tried watching him closely this game and i honestly could not pick out a single positive thing he did.

When is the last time you have seen mini, make contact with a player who busts the line ? I'm not even talking about try-savers. Just contact.

- The grubber that they scored from - although you cannot lay any blame with him for the try - was he even in the area ? He wasn't within two frames of the ball. Every fullback i watch is always there-abouts, even if they can't stop the try.

- Fulton's try - didn't even make contact. Lets face it, the odds of stopping it were minimal but Mini just had the good old air-swing,

- The 30 year old fijian's 'NO TRY' - wtf was he doing ? He closed on Utai but then hesitated. For farks sake, either commit and put pressure on the kick like a good fullback or position yourself for the kick trusting your chasers. He was left standing in no man's land. It's not as though he is inexperienced.

- Constant line clogging and rubbish dummy half running.

- Constantly getting dominated on kick returns and starting our set on the back foot.


I really hope he scores the try for the record, but the longer he takes, the longer we suffer.

[Cockadoodledoo]

Oh man, where do you start with the Count.

I tried watching him closely this game and i honestly could not pick out a single positive thing he did.

When is the last time you have seen mini, make contact with a player who busts the line ? I'm not even talking about try-savers. Just contact.

- The grubber that they scored from - although you cannot lay any blame with him for the try - was he even in the area ? He wasn't within two frames of the ball. Every fullback i watch is always there-abouts, even if they can't stop the try.

- Fulton's try - didn't even make contact. Lets face it, the odds of stopping it were minimal but Mini just had the good old air-swing,

- The 30 year old fijian's 'NO TRY' - wtf was he doing ? He closed on Utai but then hesitated. For farks sake, either commit and put pressure on the kick like a good fullback or position yourself for the kick trusting your chasers. He was left standing in no man's land. It's not as though he is inexperienced.

- Constant line clogging and rubbish dummy half running.

- Constantly getting dominated on kick returns and starting our set on the back foot.


I really hope he scores the try for the record, but the longer he takes, the longer we suffer.

Mike, Mini got the record up at Newcastle the other week.. People bagged Graham last week for his kick returns, can anyone remember the last time be made a line break from a kick return? At least Graham made one last week, I think Mini hasn't made one since 2005.

[Guest]

Mike, Mini got the record up at Newcastle the other week.. People bagged Graham last week for his kick returns, can anyone remember the last time be made a line break from a kick return? At least Graham made one last week, I think Mini hasn't made one since 2005.

I thought he tied it?

Edit:

I have given up on Mini being an attacking weapon a long time ago.

Now i am just happy if he stays out of playmaking and doesn't fark up. The only thing he had going for him is his defence at the back. Sadly, that too is no longer there.

[Guest]

.. and just before i go to bed, i just want to make a big shout-out to my boy SKD who never fails to disappoint.

That pass was one for the vault.

I think you could make a great youtube clip with all his dumbarse errors.

1 mill. contract, well deserved.

At least he is learning how to draw and pass. Slowly.

[Guest]

.. and just before i go to bed, i just want to make a big shout-out to my boy SKD who never fails to disappoint.

That pass was one for the vault.

I think you could make a great youtube clip with all his dumbarse errors.

1 mill. contract, well deserved.

At least he is learning how to draw and pass. Slowly.

Mike, I think it is becoming contagious this year. They can't seem to string much together without it failing. Last year things just seemed to go our way. SKD's year is just going the same way as the rest of the team...Poor.
Better luck next year mate.

[Guest]

Mike, I think it is becoming contagious this year. They can't seem to string much together without it failing. Last year things just seemed to go our way. SKD's year is just going the same way as the rest of the team...Poor.
Better luck next year mate.

Don't get me wrong, SKD is a great strike centre. However, the type of errors he makes are very comical.

[Guest]

I'd like to see all you haters to go out there and do a better job than todd.

[Johnny Tobin]

I'd like to see all you haters to go out there and do a better job than todd.

LOL

What he said........





Not.

[bondi-boy]

Sandow won the game for Souths with a 51m field goal.

He and Carney are 'never' going to be able to tackle players twice or 1 1/2 times their size....on their own.

[Guest]

Sandow won the game for Souths with a 51m field goal.

He and Carney are 'never' going to be able to tackle players twice or 1 1/2 times their size....on their own.

Point is BB, that 'Alfie' has a red hot go and puts his body on the line.

Fulton ran straight through Carney like he wasn't there. Fulton isn't exactly a blockbusting monster.

[stsae]

Carntage really struggles with expectations.

Last season, no pressure, just a fresh start, the man really played great footy looking relaxed, all coq it was.

This year hes played like a man scared of his own shadow, like hes struggling to get it up. His defence especially, which we all know is mostly attitude, is woeful.

Get back on the cans Toad. I dont give a fark what you do outside footy, just get it back, the Eddie Murphy swagger.

Who gives a fark what the tellucrapp write about, I dont read it and havent missed wasting my time this season in doing so.

[elo]

Whilst Toddy did miss the tackle, Anasta created the hole for Fulton to run at by rushing up and grabbing Lui 3 seconds after he had passed the ball instead of just sliding and filling the gap. He did the opposite last week to **** up on a Luke try.

Get a proper ****ing second rower inside Carney, Lockyer has had the likes of Carroll and Thaiday inside him his whole career to mind him, Carney should have the same. Aubusson or Cordner would do.

[bigben]

Carntage really struggles with expectations.

Last season, no pressure, just a fresh start, the man really played great footy looking relaxed, all coq it was.

This year hes played like a man scared of his own shadow, like hes struggling to get it up. His defence especially, which we all know is mostly attitude, is woeful.

Get back on the cans Toad. I dont give a fark what you do outside footy, just get it back, the Eddie Murphy swagger.

Who gives a fark what the tellucrapp write about, I dont read it and havent missed wasting my time this season in doing so.

The way he's been playing i don't think he's been off it !!!