Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

NRL announces judiciary code reforms

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • NRL announces judiciary code reforms

    NRL.com

    -

    February 2, 2017 - 3:15 pm A fines system will be introduced for some low-grade offences following an extensive review of the NRL Judiciary system.

    Offences including careless high tackles, tripping, contrary conduct and detrimental conduct will now result in a $1500 fine for a Grade One offence, rather than demerit points and possible suspension. Players who accept an early guilty plea will have the fine reduced by 25 per cent.



    A Working Group which included representatives of NRL Clubs, the Rugby League Players Association and legal representatives of the NRL Judiciary system unanimously supported a hybrid model which incorporates both fines and points.
    Other more serious offences including dangerous throws, shoulder charges, kicking and striking will still result in points penalties for Grade One offences.

    “Where a player is involved in dangerous actions they can still expect to spend time on the sideline,” NRL Head of Football Brian Canavan said.
    “These changes are the result of an extensive review of the previous process and extensive consultation.
    “The aim of the Working Group was to find a fairer and simpler system which ensured players would not miss matches for what would be deemed minor offences.”
    All fines must be paid by the player and the revenue generated by the payment of fines will be reinvested in player wellbeing and education related initiatives.
    Players who are charged with three or more offences during the same season will not be eligible to accept a financial penalty. In those circumstances, offences will be converted to a base penalty of 100 demerit points.
    Additionally, following the recommendations of the Match Review/Judiciary review, which were endorsed by the Australian Rugby League Commission this week:
    • Some offences will now carry lower points, while the base penalty for some offences stemming from careless, reckless or intentional conduct has increased;
    • The categories of offences have been streamlined, decreasing from 17 to 12. This is designed to ensure easier explanation and understanding for all;
    • Offences will now universally carry three grades, although offences which are deemed to be more serious than a Grade Three offence will be referred directly to the Judiciary Panel;
    • Carry-over points will be not added to charges which attract a fine. However, loadings from offences in the previous two seasons will be relevant for calculating penalties;
    • The Match Review Committee will be reduced from five panel members to four, with former NRL Coach Stuart Raper joining Michael Buettner, Michael Hodgson and Ben Ross on the panel in 2017;
    • The Judiciary Panel will be cut from a nine-person panel to five, and;
    • Judiciary hearings will be held on Tuesday nights.
    “These changes are designed to both simplify the system and improve consistency across the decision-making of both the Match Review Committee and the NRL Judiciary,” Mr Canavan said.
    The Working Group which recommended the changes included Bulldogs Coach Des Hasler, Club CEOs Jim Doyle and Graham Annesley, RLPA General Manager Player Relations Clint Newton, Judiciary Chairman Geoff Bellew, former NRL Counsel Peter Kite as well as key NRL officials including Head of Integrity Nick Weeks and Brian Canavan.
    “This Working Group researched, documented, explored and then pressure-tested penalties for minor offences across major sporting competitions domestically and across the globe,” Mr Canavan said.
    “Our benchmarking analysis researched best-practice models from American sports, including the NFL, NBA and MLB, as well as competitions closer to home.
    “Importantly, all of these important changes follow extensive consultation with stakeholders – including the Clubs, the Coaches and the Players.
    “The result will be a far more streamlined, fairer system which will be easier to understand and appreciate for everyone in the game.”
    The new system will be in place for the start of the 2017 NRL Telstra Premiership.



  • #2
    We'll see how it goes, but I like the idea of having a fine. Of course, clubs will probably pay them more often than not (so it's just a money grab from the clubs) but IMO it's really annoying when players get like 5 week suspensions all because they've plead guilty to a heap of BS little offences that woulda been 'play on' if the ref had treated both teams equally when handing out on-field penalties.

    The only other quirk with these fines is that players earn vastly different salaries. So for example if Vunacece gets a $1500 fine then he's on about the same salary if not less than what I'm on so he'd be like 'BEEEEEEEEEEEEP!!!! $1500?!?!? SHIZZLE MAN... THAT IS HARSH FOR ONE LITTLE CARELESS MOVE!!!' Whereas guys like DCE, Hunt, JT, Smith, RTS, GI...etc would be like 'mmmkay get my wallet out of the locker'.

    As such, I think this fine system is a blatant money grab. There's no mechanism preventing clubs from paying the fine (although arguably that'd put them over the cap I guess?) and there's LOTS of players out there (arguably less talented ones, more prone to making 'careless' tackles) who I would suggest would struggle to foot a $1500 bill after their repayments on a Sydney mortgage and (potentially) single income paying for their family.

    It's like the $80 parking fines at Mosman... will we see guys like Smith just doing intentionally 'careless' tackles (with theatrics and all... 'oh it was an accident sir!!!') now because it benefits them and the fine's a nothing fine that'll probably be footed by the club anyway. OR... will it just sting less talented players for making silly mistakes? I guess if it does you can just take the week off, but still... if you're battling for a starting spot, you may not have that option on your cards.
    Last edited by ism22; 02-02-2017, 07:45 PM.

    Comment


    • #3
      Haven't looked at the detail, but sounds a terrific idea.

      Comment


      • #4
        Jared will be bankrupt by April.

        Comment


        • #5
          The only other quirk with these fines is that players earn vastly different salaries. So for example if Vunacece gets a $1500 fine then he's on about the same salary if not less than what I'm on so he'd be like 'BEEEEEEEEEEEEP!!!! $1500?!?!? SHIZZLE MAN... THAT IS HARSH FOR ONE LITTLE CARELESS MOVE!!!' Whereas guys like DCE, Hunt, JT, Smith, RTS, GI...etc would be like 'mmmkay get my wallet out of the locker'.
          Not sure that's how it's playing out, tbh.

          The way I see this, is that (for once) the NRL is genuinely applying a common sense manoeuvre, where for the first time since that corporate narcissist David Smith banned the punch - like the Focus Group incompetent that he was - they're actually lessening the severity of certain offences that are going to happen inevitibly, so that players don't accrue so many points as it's just too much of a pointless liability for teams to be hamstrung for the occasional brain fart trip or whatever.

          Clubs would totally foot the bill on these (certainly for low earners).

          I think this is borne out somewhat by the decision to reinvest that money into worthy, RL-associated programs.
          Making Steve Naughton look like Vince Mellars...

          Comment


          • #6
            I also like the reduction in numbers of the new Judiciary. Parra should be in decent shape with 2 ex-players on the panel, with Beuttner and Michael Hodgson passing judgement from upon high.
            Making Steve Naughton look like Vince Mellars...

            Comment


            • #7
              If one of our players trips Josh Reynolds I'll happily contribute towards the fine. $1500. BARGAIN!

              Comment


              • #8
                money grab by the nrl. where will they spend the money. Player welfare, hahahaha yeh right.

                i can see the like of smiff and co milking the living shit out of the smallest infringement, milking a grade 1 offence to and escalated laydown sally routine ala matai school of acting grade three offence.
                1911 1912 1913 1923 1935 1936 1937 1940 1945 1974 1975 2002 2013 2018 2019 2020

                Comment

                Working...
                X