Shock me Rothfield has us finishing 10th

[Guest]

I would love to be paid for doing a job that allows you to give your personal opinion on a sport you love, without the need for any real expertise or knowledge!
I agreed with what "supermario" () said on Phil's blog yesterday.
Tried to reply but he always boots me.
I am annoyed with Todd but fail to see the comparison between low range
driving and sexual assault whilst paralytic like Stewart!

[Rooster_6]

10th is one of the more unlikely spots we'll finish this year imo, more chance we'll finish last.

[theGman]

his 50 best players in the nrl last year was actually hilarious...he'd make a better comedian..he must be depressed enough

50-41
50. Blake Ferguson
49. Alan Tongue
48. Ben Hornby
47. John Sutton
46. David Stagg
45. Roy Asotasi
44. Jamie Lyon
43. Josh Dugan
42. Chris Lawrence
41. Luke Lewis

40-31
40. Manu Vatuvei
39. Daniel Mortimer
38. Jarrod Mullen
37. Luke O'Donnell
36. Adam Blair
35. Dave Taylor
34. Terry Campese
33. Todd Carney
32. Jamie Soward
31. Steve Price

30-21
30. Greg Bird
29. Justin Hodges
28. Petero Civoniceva
27. Michael Ennis
26. Israel Folau
25. Brett Stewart
24. Ben Hannant
23. Ben Creagh
22. Jared Waerea-Hargreaves
21. Cooper Cronk

20-11
20. Brett Morris
19. Brett Kmmorley
18. Josh Morris
17. Feleti Mateo
16. Sam Burgess
15. Beniji Marshall
14. Kurt Gidley
13. Darren Lockyer
12. Robbie Farah
11. Nathan Hindmarsh

10-1
10. Fuifui Moimoi
9. Michael Jennings
8. Paul Gallen
7. Scott Prince
6. Anthony Watmough
5. Cameron Smith
4. Johnathan Thurston
3. Jarryd Hayne
2. Billy Slater
1. Greg Inglis

What! He needs his head read.

We finished 6th after 26 rounds and spent most of the year in the top 8 but in his "humble"opinion only 2 Roosters players make his 50?? And one of them JWH missed the first 10-12 rounds . No room for Mitchell Pearce, Anasta or Maubs. Well i'll be fcuked!

Also, please correct me if i'm wrong but Steve Price didn't play a game last year for the Warriors due to a foot injury however the numbskull has him listed as number 31.

Time to get off the drink pisshead or better still, do everyone in Rugby League a favour and find a nursing home. ROTHFIELD HAS NO FCUKEN IDEA

[BUDDY]

What! He needs his head read.

We finished 6th after 26 rounds and spent most of the year in the top 8 but in his "humble"opinion only 2 Roosters players make his 50?? And one of them JWH missed the first 10-12 rounds . No room for Mitchell Pearce, Anasta or Maubs. Well i'll be fcuked!

Also, please correct me if i'm wrong but Steve Price didn't play a game last year for the Warriors due to a foot injury however the numbskull has him listed as number 31.

Time to get off the drink pisshead or better still, do everyone in Rugby League a favour and find a nursing home. ROTHFIELD HAS NO FCUKEN IDEA

Interesting where he placed the top three Dally M players.

The defense rests your honour.

[Guest]

his 50 best players in the nrl last year was actually hilarious...he'd make a better comedian..he must be depressed enough

50-41
50. Blake Ferguson
49. Alan Tongue
48. Ben Hornby
47. John Sutton
46. David Stagg
45. Roy Asotasi
44. Jamie Lyon
43. Josh Dugan
42. Chris Lawrence
41. Luke Lewis

40-31
40. Manu Vatuvei
39. Daniel Mortimer
38. Jarrod Mullen
37. Luke O'Donnell
36. Adam Blair
35. Dave Taylor
34. Terry Campese
33. Todd Carney
32. Jamie Soward
31. Steve Price

30-21
30. Greg Bird
29. Justin Hodges
28. Petero Civoniceva
27. Michael Ennis
26. Israel Folau
25. Brett Stewart
24. Ben Hannant
23. Ben Creagh
22. Jared Waerea-Hargreaves
21. Cooper Cronk

20-11
20. Brett Morris
19. Brett Kmmorley
18. Josh Morris
17. Feleti Mateo
16. Sam Burgess
15. Beniji Marshall
14. Kurt Gidley
13. Darren Lockyer
12. Robbie Farah
11. Nathan Hindmarsh

10-1
10. Fuifui Moimoi
9. Michael Jennings
8. Paul Gallen
7. Scott Prince
6. Anthony Watmough
5. Cameron Smith
4. Johnathan Thurston
3. Jarryd Hayne
2. Billy Slater
1. Greg Inglis

Where's Gary Warburton? The guy is a niff nuff!!

[Chookies74]

Hodges was out for the whole year
Mortimer above Luke Lewis, and Lewis no. 40
Where's Tom Leroy Largearse
delusional

[fletch]

the funny thing is he will come out and pick the Sharkies in the top 4 and for Gallen to captain NSW, he is no better than a radio shock jock, certainly not a quality league journo, Chippy Frilingos would be turning in his grave.

[ism22]

Good let the fools talk us down... we always seem to win after people have said "the Roosters have no hope."

All I have to say is when we make the finals, Mr Rotherfield can't then go saying "THE ROOSTERS ARE THE BIGGEST CHOKERS"... a title many seemed to like giving us last season, although at the start of the season nobody expected us to make the finals.

We need a website where columnists can lock in their opinions for the season, then be judged on what they're saying at the end of the season. That way if people predict a team will come 10th, they can't call them chokers when they lose a grand final... well they can, but they'll look dumb.

[Guest]

2011 will certainly be interesting!

[Guest]

JT and Inglis missed half of the season. How can he have them in the top 10?

[ism22]

8046 members up on the site right now by the way...
One thing's sure... people will be out there backing us!!

[Billy Gunn]

10th I'm surprised he has us that high

[Guest]

phil hes obviously a bit special.probabley get a run in the circus with a head like that.what a clown.

[Guest]

I can't believe that, given his choice in footy teams, he is actually paid to give his opinion on the game of rugby league.

So much so, I stopped reading his tripe years ago. I won't even read it even if someone else has paid the $1 for the rag.

[Guest]

No Kenny Dowel in that top 50????

4 words come to mind for this hobo

COCK GOBBLING CUM GARGLER

That is all