The man who will keep perret leilua graham and linnet fighting for there spot!

[Guest]

THE TANK!!!!!!!!http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nvf6ScaM314 Iknow its old but he,s an exiting prospect for 2011..........see a young Hargeaves frustated atempt at stopping Carney,s try against manly!

[Guest]

what a good player he is

too good not to be in first grade

[supermario]

He is such a STRONG finisher !!!

You get the ball to him running close to the line..........Rack it up as a try !

[The General]

THE TANK!!!!!!!!http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nvf6ScaM314 Iknow its old but he,s an exiting prospect for 2011..........see a young Hargeaves frustated atempt at stopping Carney,s try against manly!

Hmmm "Short Memory"? I wonder if that was directed at Canberra officials?

[supermario]

I said the same thing general when i sent the link to a raiders mate of mine

[alex0063]

He will be playing round 1

[elo]

He will be playing round 1

I sense the same, for either Linnett or BJ.

[Guest]

Linnett will surely be first pick out of BJ and Carney. I would put Linnett ahead of Perrett as well.

I was shot down for suggesting it last year but I still say that Perrett will be struggling to retain his wing spot in the near future.

[BUDDY]

If Perrett and Carney are both in the team, I can see them causing havoc out of dummy half from both sides of the field.

I think Graham may struggle to play one game this year barring injury.

[alex0063]

Isnt Graham injured for round 1 anyways and if Carney has a big game on saturday night there no reason why smithy wouldnt put him in for round 1

[Guest]

If Perrett and Carney are both in the team, I can see them causing havoc out of dummy half from both sides of the field.

I think Graham may struggle to play one game this year barring injury.

The NRL are attempting to slow down the play-the-ball. I can't see our small men wreaking havoc from dummy half as they did last year.

[Guest]

If Perrett and Carney are both in the team, I can see them causing havoc out of dummy half from both sides of the field.

I think Graham may struggle to play one game this year barring injury.

BJ will also be very strong running the ball up on the 1st or 2nd after a kick. Will run the ball up like th 2nd rower he is. Looks like this is a trait Smith definitely wants from his wing men.

Good bye Phil Graham

[Guest]

Smith sees bj as a winger and carney as a centre. I've been told linnett is the one who really has to perform this week to keep his spot. So it could be skd and carney in the centers. It surprises me as I really see carney as a winger and you def couldn't put carney and bj on the same side as we would get bombed all day. If he goes with those players I'd rather bj in the centers and carney on the wing but smith would know more than me

[Guest]

BJ is a defensive liability on the wing. There is no way Smith will keep him there ahead of Graham or Linnett.

[supermario]

BJ to me is a 2nd rower

My back 5 would be

Mini
Perrett
Linnett
SKD
J Carney.