Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Finally, proof the media are full of shit and have NFI

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Finally, proof the media are full of shit and have NFI

    Roosters v Panthers player ratings
    Daniel Lane
    September 19, 2010

    1. Anthony Minichiello Excelled under the high ball, injected himself into attack. All class. 8/10

    2. Phil Graham A danger whenever he had the ball, tormented with a number of breaks. 7/10

    3. Kane Linnett Helped to terrorise the left side of field. Some solid defence. 7/10

    4. Shaun Kenny-Dowall Ran roughshod over the Penrith backline. Adds a genuine toughness out wide. 8/10

    5. Sam Perrett Proved he is one of the NRL's great finishers. Seizes opportunities. 7/10

    6. Todd Carney Another masterful display. Is maturing into a great player who inspires his teammates. 9/10

    7. Mitchell Pearce Cut Penrith to ribbons with his ability to read the play, kick and pass. 9/10

    8. Jason Ryles Gave the Roosters plenty of go forward and absorbed punishment. 7/10

    9. Jake Friend Played smart at dummy half, setting the tone with quick and decisive passes. 7/10

    10. Frank-Paul Nuuausala Helped soften the Panthers up with strong play. 7/10

    11. Braith Anasta Involved in everything, didn't allow his players to relax. 9/10

    12. Mitch Aubusson Hammered the defensive line constantly. 7/10

    13. Nate Myles Ran great angles. Laid a wonderful foundation. 8/10

    INTERCHANGE

    14. Martin Kennedy Enforced his will on the game. 7/10

    15. Jared Waerea-Hargreaves Instilled fear, some Penrith players seemed to look for him. 7/10

    16. Daniel Conn Another solid interchange player, who gains yards the hard way. 7/10

    17. James Aubusson Added to Penrith's woes with his physical play. Gave the defensive line no respite. 7/10

    PANTHERS

    21. Lachlan Coote His courageous tackle to chop down tryline-bound Jake Friend typified his game. 8/10

    2. Sandor Earl Involved himself from the wing and didn't need to look too hard for work. 7/10

    3. Michael Jennings Injured his ankle in the third minute, replaced in the eighth. 2/10

    4. Brad Tighe Tried to adjust to being without Jennings, but couldn't repel the swarms out wide. 6/10

    1. Michael Gordon Started well, but Roosters were ruthless. 6/10

    6. Travis Burns Never-surrender attitude. He even shaped up to Jared Waerea-Hargraves. 6/10

    7. Luke Walsh Produced a 'Benji' flick pass to set up a try. A class player even on a bad day. 8/10

    8. Sam McKendry Started game with a head full of steam and maintained the rage. 7/10

    9. Kevin Kingston Threw himself into the game, but couldn't generate momentum. 6/10

    10. Petero Civoniceva Short of a run but he tried to rally his team, leading by example. 7/10

    11. Nathan Smith Played his 100th top-grade game. It must have felt like his 1000th. 6/10

    5. Adrian Purtell Started in the forwards but shunted to three-quarters for Jennings. 6/10

    13. Luke Lewis Badly concussed in the 24th minute, returned 40 minutes later but game couldn't be salvaged. 6/10

    INTERCHANGE

    12. Gavin Cooper Another whose game was ruined by injury. 6/10

    15. Mathew Bell Made an immediate impact with a big break, but encountered a tough defence. 6/10

    17. Frank Puletua Thrown into the fray earlier than expected. 5/10

    20. Wade Graham Crawled on his hands and knees to score. 7/10


    just goes to show how all these morons writing crap about our boys week in and week out really have no clue what they are doing.... mistaking BJ for JAubs.... ****n so called experts... i would like to give them a few expert side kicks to the head and then some.... GO ROOOSTERS!!!!!

  • #2
    Yes, I noticed that too and it didn't surprise me given josh crakic's BS ratings last week.
    The other line that is a bit dodgy is this one ...

    2. Phil Graham A danger whenever he had the ball, tormented with a number of breaks. 7/10

    Phil played all of what, 15 minutes?
    "The price of freedom is eternal vigilance."

    Thomas Jefferson

    Comment


    • #3
      Luke Walsh 8/10 ????? That 1 flick pass was all he did.. He is a useless git...

      Comment


      • #4
        Hilarious ratings, why do they bother?

        Comment


        • #5
          It is almost like they didn't watch the game.

          They commented on Jennings, Cooper and Lewis going off the field injured, yet seemed to overlook that Graham went off the field.

          Nuuausala did NOTHING last night. Had a great game last week but last night we might as well have played with 16 men. He is too good a player to drop, but he deserves nothing more than a 5/10, simply for not doing anything wrong.

          Perrett and SKD should swap ratings. Perrett was outstanding, 8 is warranted, SKD was solid, 7 is warranted.

          Hargreaves deserved an 8 IMO. When he came on the field, yet again the team lifted.

          Comment


          • #6
            Sam Perrett Proved he is one of the NRL's great finishers

            I'm a big fan of Sammy, but he is hardly one of the best finishers. he has a shocking strike rate

            Comment


            • #7
              hargreaves had one of his best games tonight an 8 for sure. I think this guy just guessed and really rating a player who didn't even play is pathetic

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by Comrade View Post
                Sam Perrett Proved he is one of the NRL's great finishers

                I'm a big fan of Sammy, but he is hardly one of the best finishers. he has a shocking strike rate
                Sam proved what a great finisher he was with his second try. Most players would have just forced the ball, but he panicked and tried to pick it up and in the process bombed it (but was saved by benefit of the doubt).

                Imagine if we are in the Grand Final and we are 2 behind with a minute to play, Carney grubbers into the in goal, Perrett is first to the ball and instead of forcing the ball to win the game he tries to pick it up and fluffs it.

                Credit where its due he is excellent out of dummy half and is really helping to get us on the front foot, but for a guy that has played over 100 FG games he makes some basic and just plain dumb errors.

                Comment


                • #9
                  I had to have a laugh

                  This guy has no ****ing idea

                  The highlight has to be the 8/10 for Luke Walsh, funniest shit I have read in a while.

                  He is such a "class player" Smithy got rid of him at the knights because he is crap.

                  And we all thought the TeleCrap had ALL the worst sports reporters, this guy from the Sydney Morning Herald just gave his 'job application article'. Buzz and Bec's just added another tool to the TeleCrap toolshed

                  Crikey

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by crikey chris View Post
                    And we all thought the TeleCrap had ALL the worst sports reporters
                    They're proving they still are after today's article courtesy of Bec and Buzz.

                    FORGET the denials coming from the Roosters camp - Braith Anasta definitely wants out and is a realistic chance of playing for the Cowboys in 2011 - or maybe even the Parramatta Eels.Anasta hasn't been happy since being switched into the pack by coach Brian Smith this season, and his manager Greg Willett has been telling rival clubs his client is ready, willing and able to make a move next year, even though he's under contract for another season. Anasta is too professional to talk publicly about his situation at the Roosters. The dark horse in all this is the Parramatta Eels. They tried for Brett Kimmorley and missed out. They tried for Trent Barrett and missed out. They tried for Quade Cooper and missed out. Now there's talk Anasta would be a great one-year option before Cooper agrees to switch codes in 2012. A lot will depend on Anasta's squeeze Jodi Gordon. We hear their relationship is going from strength to strength and she would prefer to stay in Sydney.
                    it begs belief that they're still trying to push it, and then this

                    WE'VE told you many times you can't trust the other Sunday newspaper's sport coverage. Here's another example why. Two weeks ago they ran a story under the headline - 'Thursty lays off the drink in bid to retain Roos spot' about Johnathan Thurston. Hmmm. "I've been off the drink since I did the injury and I'm pretty determined to give myself the chance of the quickest recovery and be ready for the Four Nations," Thurston told the newspaper, before commenting: "Those close to him are adamant they've never seen the 27-year-old more focused." He didn't look too focused as he walked out of a Brisbane police cell on Thursday morning.
                    as if it's a paper's fault if a player is full of sh*t and lies about what he does and doesn't do.

                    On second thought...they're all ****ing stupid.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      To Walsh's credit he made a couple of try saving tackles
                      The Internet is a place for posting silly things
                      Try and be serious and you will look stupid
                      sigpic

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X