The hit on JWH in in the semi against Wests isnt a send off. But that hit on Rose was... that is extraordinary.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
How long will JWH be out for?
Collapse
X
-
That was bs to say the least. Worthy of a penalty yes, report maybe, send off... definitely not.
Rose was falling into the tackle.Comment of the year:
Andrew Johns, Semi-Final vs North Queensland ,
"It's touched Lui's hand and travelled forward but that's not a knock on"
Comment
-
I've got no problems with the sendoff. He caught him flush on the head with a swinging arm. We'd be blowing up if one of our players got hit like that.
Where fans get angry is the lack of consistency in it. There's been worse tackles than that this year, and far more dangerous spear tackles, that needed to be sendoffs.
If the refs are consistent and send off players from this point for tackles like that then it's all good.
If not, JWH can feel hard done by.
I think it was worth 2 weeks.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Ghost of Finch View PostI've got no problems with the sendoff. He caught him flush on the head with a swinging arm. We'd be blowing up if one of our players got hit like that.
Where fans get angry is the lack of consistency in it. There's been worse tackles than that this year, and far more dangerous spear tackles, that needed to be sendoffs.
If the refs are consistent and send off players from this point for tackles like that then it's all good.
If not, JWH can feel hard done by.
I think it was worth 2 weeks.
Comment
-
With all the media garbage over refs not using the send off rule enough i guess JWH will be one they make a example of with Steve Matai,should only be a one week suspension,i loved the way he turned around to the team after copping the send off and geed them up,it's easy to say after the fact but when i saw that i knew the boy's wouldn't let him down.
Comment
Comment