Response To Rothfield re Minichiello

[stsae]

Fair reply Newman.

I was hoping youd say Kramer or Seinfeld wrote it, no Georgie Boy.

As I said I don't disagree with most of the email, I just thought the way it all came about here and now seems a little agenda driven.

I'm not a fan of Rothwitt. And I don't read his shit anyways.

I love the club and Rothwitt may very well find a way to use such a email to destabilize the club in some way. At minimum it will only fuel his ego that his opinion is being sought and actually matters.

While it may be true I don't agree dealing with that piece of shit is the way to achieve anything positive for us.

[kurtsherlock6]

Warning....agenda agenda.

What a load of tripe. They are obviously on a mission to destroy mini but I think he's bigger than these sick individuals.

Fortunately his teammates and coach dont agree...along with the real supporters.

Very appropriate to peddle this destabilising content to the master destabiliser....Roth field!!!

Yeah, but what would they know?

[Spirit of 66]

Another person for my ignore list...

[Guest]

Maybe after seeing the club sign, re-sign and re-sign this player over and over again, despite him obviously not being up to scatch, and to find him still playing fullback with no sign in sight of anyone having the guts to move him has led him to take whatever measures are available to get this message across. I am just a casual Rooster supporter but if I was a fanatic and loved the club and knew as much about footy as the bloke that wrote this email I might have given the club a year or two to act, but after that I'd reckon you'd be entitled to tear your hair out seeing this bloke still wearing the No. 1. I must admit it seems more than strange to me too that he's still playing fullback in the NRL. Surely is what he wrote is totally wrong Rothfield could not possibly use it against the Roosters. One anonymous supporter writes an email to a gibberer like Rothfield and people on this forum have apoplexy. If he's such a champion he and you would just laugh this off.

[Guest]

Where's the letter outlining how crap Pearce and Friend are?

What's taking you so long to pen it Raygoat?

[SConcierge]

What a sad sad prick pretending to be a roosters supporter, some clowns just think they know it all coaching from their PC and their couch.

[Andrew Walker]

What a sad sad prick pretending to be a roosters supporter, some clowns just think they know it all coaching from their PC and their couch.

I agree its a sad cretin But sadly I think this sick little puppy is one of our own

[stsae]

Maybe after seeing the club sign, re-sign and re-sign this player over and over again, despite him obviously not being up to scatch, and to find him still playing fullback with no sign in sight of anyone having the guts to move him has led him to take whatever measures are available to get this message across. I am just a casual Rooster supporter but if I was a fanatic and loved the club and knew as much about footy as the bloke that wrote this email I might have given the club a year or two to act, but after that I'd reckon you'd be entitled to tear your hair out seeing this bloke still wearing the No. 1. I must admit it seems more than strange to me too that he's still playing fullback in the NRL. Surely is what he wrote is totally wrong Rothfield could not possibly use it against the Roosters. One anonymous supporter writes an email to a gibberer like Rothfield and people on this forum have apoplexy. If he's such a champion he and you would just laugh this off.

So is your problem with management or Mini or both???

Why are you so bothered with this agenda when you are just a "casual Roosters supporter"???

Are you paid by the word???

You seem to talk in a familiar all knowing all seeing way Newman. Geez mate after round 2 and the players are trying to get it together with a decent squad the clubs built and we have an agenda against the captain of the club.

A "casual Roosters supporter".

[roosterproud]

hey newman i love your m.a.d magazines

[milanja]

Rothfield prob doesnt bring it up cos he thinks chooks will do better if we do get rid of him!

[Hawkeye]

but I would not have thought that a man with your journalistic integrity would be a party to this continuing protection racket. .

Sorry ...thats where the article lost me !

[mightyrooster]

This has a very bad smell to it.

[Guest]

Its amazing what e-mails you can find in your outbox.

[Guest]

as much as this is an agenda driven post by some f@rkwit with the intent to antagonise, mini himself would be disappointed with the first try which came from yet another dropped inside ball to him and then the third try which he could have dealt with far better.

mini makes errors but he is our leader, he is not perfect anymore but he still puts his body on the line for the tricolors.

i will never forget when he broke his ankle and still ran 10 meters to score a try, that is a true captain of this great club.

go fu^& off elsewhere with your trolling posts

[Guest]

I am confused as to why somebody would reach out to Phil "Buzz" Rothfield to objectively write about the Roosters in such a way that would benefit the club, in the writers opinion.