Nice to hear, Uncle Nick has been buissy.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Falou and Sbw Roosters in 2013.
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by rob1crap View PostThe same source that told me Myles and Graham were going to Titans, Carney to Sharks and Maloney and Sbw to Roosters. Yet the Mods like threaten me with a bann for information from player managers. Go figure!
Comment
-
as much as i think this is just bait, the folau, lewis and SBW situation is likely to surface over the next little while anyway so might as well give my 2 cents worth...
I dont think we need folau. We have moga, RTS, SKD, tagive, leilua, oldfield forming a really strong nucleus. I also think that the folau style player we have covered in SKD and moga.
Considering SBW looks certain to come I also dont think it would be wise for us to have 2 players swapping codes on massive money coming to us in the same year considering Folau's body shape has changed drastically and SBW will need to aclimatise to the speed of the NRL. Both have also been out of the game for 2 years minimum which is quite a while. Would be very risky imo and cost us a few of our talented youngsters which I am adverse to.
In summary, folau - no; SBW/lewis - one of the two wouldnt hurt but I am nervous about SBW in particular considering he has been away from NRL for so long playing with a really low workrate than what would be required in league along with the issues that the boxing/japanese rugby/bulldogs games would cause
Comment
-
Originally posted by roz View Postas much as i think this is just bait, the folau, lewis and SBW situation is likely to surface over the next little while anyway so might as well give my 2 cents worth...
I dont think we need folau. We have moga, RTS, SKD, tagive, leilua, oldfield forming a really strong nucleus. I also think that the folau style player we have covered in SKD and moga.
Considering SBW looks certain to come I also dont think it would be wise for us to have 2 players swapping codes on massive money coming to us in the same year considering Folau's body shape has changed drastically and SBW will need to aclimatise to the speed of the NRL. Both have also been out of the game for 2 years minimum which is quite a while. Would be very risky imo and cost us a few of our talented youngsters which I am adverse to.
In summary, folau - no; SBW/lewis - one of the two wouldnt hurt but I am nervous about SBW in particular considering he has been away from NRL for so long playing with a really low workrate than what would be required in league along with the issues that the boxing/japanese rugby/bulldogs games would cause
Don't need Falou or Lewis?
We'll just keep on letting teenagers try and do a man's job for a few more years then shall we?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Greedy666 View PostI'm convinced that you like sitting at the bottom of the ladder roz.
Don't need Falou or Lewis?
We'll just keep on letting teenagers try and do a man's job for a few more years then shall we?
Im not talking the side up at all in fact I was particularly disappointed by last night however when you consider how many close games we have lost this year (mainly thanks to some shocking refereeing), you would find that we could be somewhere around 6th and peoples perceptions would be completely different. The broncos game in the rain, the dogs game at home, the first manly game (where harrigan even admitted we were robbed of a victory), the warriors game in NZ and anzac day v merge. I feel that that anzac day game was always going to define our season for a young team like ours. They put so much effort into it and lets be honest, absolutely belted st george however had it stolen at the very death. The affect that has on a side mentally as well as the momentum that a win there would have created is immense.
That all said, as I said in my original post only 1 of lewis/SBW would be good for us. Both however have downsides imo - we have players like lewis already and he is also pushing 30 and SBW hasnt played league for 4 years and has all these side deals going on at the same time so even if he completely honoured his roosters agreement and put in every week, surely the fact he is boxing and playing union in japan in the offseason would mean he is no where near as fresh as everyone else. Im not sure thats what I want out of a 800+k player.
Comment
-
Originally posted by rob1crap View PostThe same source that told me Myles and Graham were going to Titans, Carney to Sharks and Maloney and Sbw to Roosters. Yet the Mods like threaten me with a bann for information from player managers. Go figure!
get over it and the reason some times these signings dont happen is becaus e the club changes their mind at the death Ive seen it plenty -SBW,Benji ,Chris Lawrence then there was the F up with Lockyer who was to replace Freddy ...got caught before the new rules signed him before june 30th etc ...the list goes onTwo things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe
Comment
Comment