Official View: Roosters no-try the wrong call

[Waylander]

from NRL.com.....

Referee co-coach Bill Harrigan answers your most frequently asked questions from Round 11 of the NRL Telstra Premiership.

What did you think of the decision to penalise Brad Takairangi for raising his elbow in the lead-up to what would have been a try to Roosters halfback Daniel Mortimer?

The video referee got this call wrong. It should have been ruled a try to the Roosters. The video referee believed that there was a raised elbow from the ball carrier in the lead-up to Daniel Mortimer crossing the line, but he got the decision wrong.

http://www.nrl.com/official-view-roo...7/default.aspx

[Bansai Pipeline]

I'm thirsty for violence.

[Guest]

3 big games away from home (Mel, NZ and Manly) and three horrible video ref decisions that changed the course of the game.

What is going on?

[Guest]

Well it's too late now bill

[Guest]

Yet our idiot coach apparently didn't make a big deal about it after the game.

We need a new coach who actually cares

[Guest]

Ive never heard of the video ref. Anyone got any background on him? Does he know anything about nrl? Hmm im sure his middle name is neville.

[stsae]

Yet our idiot coach apparently didn't make a big deal about it after the game.

We need a new coach who actually cares

You just don't stop do you.

And he did mention it after the game, a quick snippet on FSN showed him talking about how the decision was wrong in his opinion.

Imagine if Smiff went in and gave a gobful about the decision and copped a fine you would STILL somehow angle the blame at Smiff for a dig.

You are one sick individual Fredo.

[Guest]

You just don't stop do you.

And he did mention it after the game, a quick snippet on FSN showed him talking about how the decision was wrong in his opinion.

Imagine if Smiff went in and gave a gobful about the decision and copped a fine you would STILL somehow angle the blame at Smiff for a dig.

You are one sick individual Fredo.

If you are happy with that lack of emotion & passion from our so called leader, then that's up to you. But it's no wonder many don't like him.

[stsae]

If you are happy with that lack of emotion & passion from our so called leader, then that's up to you. But it's no wonder many don't like him.

You are a farking idiot Fredo, I'm convinced now.

I have never done this to an Easts fan but I'm not bothering to respond to your shit ever again mate.

No ignore button, No anger, no hard feelings, I will just treat you like i do Lemon Scrote (I seriously doubt if he's a fan) and not read your shit. I may talk about you but I won't bother engaging you again, it's simply useless, you are a pirate and a goldfish.

Anyone can call me out on it, I will even buy them a few beers if I do.

Adios cowby.

[Guest]

In other obvious news, Craig Thomson is a liar and a thief.

[chook 56]

in other obvious news, craig thomson is a liar and a thief.

alleged!

[IRoosterManI]

Just A Little Late!

http://www.nrl.com/official-view-roo...7/default.aspx


What a Joke

[kurtsherlock6]

http://www.nrl.com/official-view-roo...7/default.aspx


What a Joke

http://www.thechookpen.com.au/forum/...the-wrong-call

Not the only one who's a little late.

[IRoosterManI]

http://www.thechookpen.com.au/forum/...the-wrong-call

Not the only one who's a little late.

Lmfao

Indeed

[Guest]

How do you post questions to bill? Any ideas?