Jerome Luai.

[Bates]

Keary is as good as any 5/8 in the game when the team is playing well and it's been a while since he's had an issue with concussion.

I'm a big no to either of them. Personal isn't the problem.

I love Keary but his concussion history is a real issue. He is potentially 1 concussion away from retirement or another 6 week recovery period on the sideline. I'd be surprised if the club offers him an extension.

[nayfo]

Good player but it would be so hard to support the team seeing him in a roosters jersey.

Sure, I would no doubt forgive and forget once we are winning games but I’d rather not even entertain the idea.

[Rooster90]

Off contract and available.

Any takers?

This is the worst thing anyone has ever suggested on this site

I'd rather Manu at hooker

[Dr. Voodoo Man]

Maybe but he is a real Penrith guy ... but so was Freddy. What is his kicking game like? Strong runner, big body, good defender.

[Bates]

Maybe but he is a real Penrith guy ... but so was Freddy. What is his kicking game like? Strong runner, big body, good defender.

His kicking game is solid. He doesn't have any flaws in his game imo. It's more his personality that appears to be the issue. The fact that Penrith haven't locked him down suggests that he wants the big bucks now. I reckon anywhere from $800k to $1 mill year. Panthers will struggle to keep players as they come off contract. Burton, Kikau, Api already gone with more leaving next year.

[Bates]

This is the worst thing anyone has ever suggested on this site

I'd rather Manu at hooker

Hi Rooster 90, You would say no to a 2 time premiership winning five-eighth who has played rep footy and is in his prime because why?

[Chook2]

Hi Rooster 90, You would say no to a 2 time premiership winning five-eighth who has played rep footy and is in his prime because why?

Just because someone has won a premiership doesn’t mean they are great, they are just in a great team
of lives in Cleary shadow and only comes out 1 in every 10 games or so and plays well
only got Origen jersey cause of Cleary partnership
he is a passenger in an amazing team that the riff has had for seasons
same as brooks a def no

[Bates]

Just because someone has won a premiership doesn’t mean they are great, they are just in a great team
of lives in Cleary shadow and only comes out 1 in every 10 games or so and plays well
only got Origen jersey cause of Cleary partnership
he is a passenger in an amazing team that the riff has had for seasons
same as brooks a def no

Are you aware that he is playing SOO 2 without Cleary as his halves partner? Most commentators thought that Luai was NSW best in game one and Cleary failed to shut the game down with only 10 to go.

There are no weak links in a premiership winning team especially in the halves.

[ism22]

Off contract and available.

Any takers?

Wouldn't turn him down at the right price... but on the same note, I wouldn't release Walker for him.

[NorfolkStreetKid]

Only if Ivan , Nathan, To'o and Leota come too.

[Dr. Voodoo Man]

His kicking game is solid. He doesn't have any flaws in his game imo. It's more his personality that appears to be the issue. The fact that Penrith haven't locked him down suggests that he wants the big bucks now. I reckon anywhere from $800k to $1 mill year. Panthers will struggle to keep players as they come off contract. Burton, Kikau, Api already gone with more leaving next year.

He could be great with Walker. Burton too. Hunt has the game but small body.

[Chook2]

Are you aware that he is playing SOO 2 without Cleary as his halves partner? Most commentators thought that Luai was NSW best in game one and Cleary failed to shut the game down with only 10 to go.

There are no weak links in a premiership winning team especially in the halves.

Yes and no one from media to supporters believes he should have had a spot and Hynes or Walker should have got the 6 jersey instead, he kept his jersey but if nsw loose he will be on the chopping block
as I said his only good game was against us before Origen before that he did f all this season
jaeman salmon is also a back to back premiership wonder so I’m saying just because he was in the side doesn’t make him a hero

there Is weak links in every side somewhere you just need to fine them

[The distributor]

Robbo at 5/8

[ism22]

Yes and no one from media to supporters believes he should have had a spot and Hynes or Walker should have got the 6 jersey instead, he kept his jersey but if nsw loose he will be on the chopping block
as I said his only good game was against us before Origen before that he did f all this season
jaeman salmon is also a back to back premiership wonder so I’m saying just because he was in the side doesn’t make him a hero

there Is weak links in every side somewhere you just need to fine them

I think Reynolds is the one they were calling for as Brisbane are dominant this season and he's played Origin before. I'd personally go with Hynes but respect the reasoning for Reynolds... don't understand Moses though.

[Kelby]

Jerome Luai

A combo of him and Walker would offer the same as Walker / Keary now.

Both are attacking players.
We need an organising half.