The Weekly Todd Carney Thread

[Guest]

Oh, you doubt it do you nostradamus?

We will never know will we.

We probably would have if we sacked Anasta instead of Carney too.

But we'll never know that either.

You are in serious denial regarding Carney's contributions and performances for us last year.

Sure, he wasn't at his best last year but i put that down to coming back too early from injury and being underdone.

You are in serious denial at the calibre of player we are talking about.

[Danish]

That's right people.... If you stick your head far enough in the sand things won't seem so bad.

Fact is we punted the best half in the world to appease players all of which will not be with us by 2013 (save for MAYBE mini). Most of the players in the senior playing group are ones which all of you people go on about every week about wanting them gone FFS!

Carney has done nothing wrong at our club except drinking less beer in a night than most the idiots on here baying for his blood put away on any given weekend.

[Guest]

I've said it before, those 4 wins at the end of last year meant jack shit against rubbish sides or teams resting their stars up for finals football.

Carney is close to the best player on the planet.

We had him.

We let him go.

All because Bwaiff suddenly decided that it was the demon drink that was the problem, when the irony is that he was!

Look at him now, on the piss every second night and carving teams up of a weekend.

Tisk, tisk, tisk...

What's your source for Braith wanting to get rid of Carney?

Was it not the decision of the Senior playing group that he couldn't be trusted anymore and had to go?

Is Braith not the leader of that senior playing group?

Farrk off with your optimistic shit 6.

The roosters DO make the wrong decision every now and then. Not that you'd ever admit it.

Sometimes the glass IS half empty.

[Rooster_6]

Was it not the decision of the Senior playing group that he couldn't be trusted anymore and had to go?

Is Braith not the leader of that senior playing group?

Farrk off with your optimistic shit 6.

The roosters DO make the wrong decision every now and then. Not that you'd ever admit it.

Sometimes the glass IS half empty.

From everything the players and club have said the players had no say it, unless you know otherwise.... hence me asking you what your source is.

For what it's worth I said the club had made the wrong decision or would be making the wrong decision if they let Carney go. Not that you'll prove otherwise as you suggested because you're full of shit.

[Guest]

Well. I'll put this here. At the Sharks he doesn't have a dud and his dud coach and a dud C.E.O. doing dud things.

And before anyone puts "why are you supporting the Roosters if you think that" I'll say that the Roosters are not Braith Anasta, Brian Smith and Steve Noyce, they are just adversely affected by them.

My question is how well were things going for Toddy at the Roosters 8 rounds in?

I too think the club should've kept him but I'm not going to blow my own horn 8 rounds in... you're just asking to get burnt when he turns back to old habits.

What old habits?

He didn't do much wrong with us bar a silly mistake driving the next morning after a big night ( which i think i recall you sticking up for him with that) and having a few quiet one's and hurting nobody.

He could kill someone for all i give a farrk.

He could have won us a few comps.

That's all i care about tbh.

[Guest]

Was it not the decision of the Senior playing group that he couldn't be trusted anymore and had to go?

Is Braith not the leader of that senior playing group?

Farrk off with your optimistic shit 6.

The roosters DO make the wrong decision every now and then. Not that you'd ever admit it.

Sometimes the glass IS half empty.

From everything the players and club have said the players had no say it, unless you know otherwise.... hence me asking you what your source is.

For what it's worth I said the club had made the wrong decision or would be making the wrong decision if they let Carney go. Not that you'll prove otherwise as you suggested because you're full of shit.

Yet you sit here defending their decision now?

Who's full of shit 6?

[Rooster_6]

What old habits?

He didn't do much wrong with us bar a silly mistake driving the next morning after a big night ( which i think i recall you sticking up for him with that) and having a few quiet one's and hurting nobody.

He could kill someone for all i give a farrk.

He could have won us a few comps.

That's all i care about tbh.

Well at least now you've admitted you're a piece of scum.

[Rooster_6]

Yet you sit here defending their decision now?

Who's full of shit 6?

Did I defend the club? Really? That's a massive assumption jump from telling John not to blow his horn too early, surely after Wednesday we'd all be a little wiser.

Although do link me where I said the club did the right thing... I'll be waiting.

[Headless Chook]

Sure, he wasn't at his best last year but i put that down to coming back too early from injury and being underdone.

You are in serious denial at the calibre of player we are talking about.

Carney's a good player, thats not in question. On his day, he's in the top half a dozen in the game.

[Guest]

You sir, are an idiot!

Tell me we would have made the GF without Carney?

Go on...tell me.

Would've been more like making the spoon favorites 3/4 into the season in 2010

But good luck to Carney and the sharks..

Goes to show how much being left alone to have a few drinks with mates

and not being hounded by everyone has him happy and performing well with

his footy (the important thing for the club and fans alike)

[Guest]

What old habits?

He didn't do much wrong with us bar a silly mistake driving the next morning after a big night ( which i think i recall you sticking up for him with that) and having a few quiet one's and hurting nobody.

He could kill someone for all i give a farrk.

He could have won us a few comps.

That's all i care about tbh.

Well at least now you've admitted you're a piece of scum.

There you go with your holier than thou attitude again 6.

That's a massive exaggeration and only a farrken idiot would take it to heart.

But then again, look who i'm talking to.

[Guest]

Yet you sit here defending their decision now?

Who's full of shit 6?

Did I defend the club? Really? That's a massive assumption jump from telling John not to blow his horn too early, surely after Wednesday we'd all be a little wiser.

Although do link me where I said the club did the right thing... I'll be waiting.

You've all but said that 6, and you know it.

You're just dirty that i agreed with Mr Walker about you being a know it all farrkwit.

[Rooster_6]

There you go with your holier than thou attitude again 6.

That's a massive exaggeration and only a farrken idiot would take it to heart.

But then again, look who i'm talking to.

Because drink driving and death is all one big joke... sorry I forgot to laugh.

His incidents at the Roosters were blown way out of proportion and I've made my views on that clear from the start I don't think he should've been punted but to think he doesn't have bad habits is delusional.

[Rooster_6]

You've all but said that 6, and you know it.

You're just dirty that i agreed with Mr Walker about you being a know it all farrkwit.

So I'll take that as a no, you can't find where I said the club made the right decision...

Full of it as usual.

[theGman]

Another thread ruined by insults etc....